Why New York Giants Are Losers At Trade Deadline

The New York Giants could've been sellers before the NFL trade deadline. They also could've been low-level buyers for an offensive skill player to help Jaxson Dart's development. The Giants are 2-7, and they're going to ride this season out with the players already in their building. MORE: Travis Hunter's injury leads to Jakobi Meyers trade The Giants didn't make any trades because the cost didn't match the desire. GM Joe Schoen didn't make any deals ahead of Tuesday's NFL trade deadline.

Ishika Samant / Getty Images Despite all the chatter, all was quiet in East Rutherford, N.J., as the NFL’s 4 p.m. ET trade deadline passed Tuesday without any activity from the New York Giants, who were neither buyers nor sellers. Only three weeks ago, standing pat seemed unlikely, as the Giants were coming off a huge prime-time win over the division rival Philadelphia Eagles and seemed poised to turn a corner behind the heroics... After losing star receiver Malik Nabers for the season to an ACL tear, rumors swirled about adding a top receiving talent to help Dart’s development, especially after the victory over Philadelphia moved the Giants... They carried that momentum of that victory into Denver and should have come away with a win.

Instead, they suffered a historic meltdown, allowing the Broncos to pull off a miraculous comeback that put the kibosh on the Giants’ good vibes. Two dismal showings, along with a season-ending injury for top rusher Cam Skattebo, have followed. The Giants are now amid a three-game losing streak and have dropped to 2-7 for the third season in a row. And here's the recording to yesterday's live room, where I continued my streak of saying I'm not that fired up … and then 20 minutes later found myself launching into an eight-minute rant on... The New York Giants aren’t mathematically out of the playoff race, but with a 2-7 record just past the halfway pole, it will take a miracle for them to come back from what has... In that position, the Giants might be looking at the future, specifically the draft, where the foundation of teams is typically built.

The more chips one has in the draft, the better, right? Yet the Giants, despite having received inquiries about free-agents-to-be Azeez Ojulari and Darius Slayton, general manager Joe Schoen, not wanting to get fleeced in any deal (or perhaps not really wanting to trade either,... But with teams realizing that Ojulari could end up an eight-game rental before hitting free agency in search of the richest possible payday, those interested at the young pass rusher out of Georgia for... The Giants lost the NFL trade battle because Schoen has shown signs of struggling to value his players correctly. To say the trade deadline didn't go the way many New York Giants fans would have hoped would be a massive understatement. Giants faithful wouldn't have even known the trade deadline had happened if it weren't for social media updates.

By the time the Eastern timezone clocks hit 4:00 p.m., general manager Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll had nothing to show for it. No help for rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart. No addition by subtraction moves, either. Related: Giants' biggest loser from directionless trade deadline is painfully obvious This was the last real shot at improving the roster before the season ends. Which all but confirms everyone in the organization is comfortable punting on 2025 — by all accounts, it's already onto the offseason.

As with every event, there are inherent winners and losers. Here they are in all their (lack of) glory. Both Meyers and Shaheed were linked to the G-Men before the trade deadline. With Malik Nabers sidelined for the year with a torn ACL, the thought was that Dart could use some playmaker help to help with the offensive lift. Well, Meyers is off to the Jacksonville Jaguars and Shaheed is off to the Seattle Seahawks, two teams in better position to win than Big Blue. The New York Giants managed to disappoint fans who wanted the club to either buy or sell ahead of Tuesday's trade deadline when the Giants did neither.

Out-of-favor offensive lineman Evan Neal and non-impact wide receiver Jalin Hyatt were among the Giants players who were reportedly available to other teams. For an article published on Wednesday, ESPN's Jeremy Fowler touched upon why those two players were still with the Giants at that time. "The Giants stood pat for a few reasons," Fowler wrote. "They were open to trading guard Neal, a former top-10 pick who's trying to revitalize his career, but did not receive enough interest. Not only are the Giants keeping wide receiver Jalin Hyatt, but my sense is he'll have a bigger role moving forward." In that same piece, ESPN's Dan Graziano mentioned that the Giants "couldn't generate any interest for [Neal], even though several teams were looking for offensive line help." That's hardly surprising considering Neal spent the...

Meanwhile, there initially was some hope that Hyatt would revive his Giants career after No. 1 receiver Malik Nabers went down with a torn ACL and meniscus in Week 4. In total, Hyatt has tallied just three receptions for 17 yards on the campaign. For what it's worth, the Giants reportedly had little interest in moving on from either defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence II or pass-rusher Kayvon Thibodeaux. Tuesday’s NFL trade deadline came and went without the New York Giants making a single move. At 2-7 and spiraling toward another lost season, Big Blue’s silence stood in stark contrast to their MetLife Stadium co-tenants, the New York Jets, who aggressively reshaped their roster.

But sometimes inaction speaks louder than any transaction — and what the Giants didn’t do reveals plenty about the franchise’s uncertain direction. Unless the team engineers a miraculous turnaround over the final eight games, head coach Brian Daboll will likely be dismissed. General manager Joe Schoen’s future, however, remains murkier. The decision to stand pat rather than trade assets like wide receiver Jalin Hyatt or offensive lineman Evan Neal for future draft capital suggests the 46-year-old general manager isn’t a lock to return next... If co-owners John Mara and Steve Tisch had given him a vote of confidence, why wouldn’t he maximize assets for the 2026 NFL Draft? Perhaps ownership doesn’t want Schoen making long-term roster decisions if his job security remains in question.

Schoen and Daboll’s working relationship dates to their Buffalo Bills tenure from 2018-2021, and Schoen hired Daboll as New York’s head coach in January 2022. The belief has been their fates are intertwined. Their collective inaction at the deadline only reinforces that connection. Fans wanted a trade, and have lost confidence in their team The New York Giants didn’t make a trade prior to the 2025 trade deadline back on Tuesday. They neither acquired a receiver to help fill out a perilously thin wide receiver depth chart, nor were they able to trade any players to add draft picks for the future.

That might not have been for lack of trying, however. We heard reports that the Giants were making calls with regards to the big name receivers like Jaylin Waddle, however the asking price was too high for the Giants’ liking. There were also reports that the Giants were fielding calls regarding players like wide receiver Jalon Hyatt and guard Evan Neal. However, it appears as though the Giants weren’t going to offload them for a pittance — which is curious considering neither seems to figure into the Giants near-term plans. But regardless of how things unfolded behind the scenes, Giants fans aren’t happy the team didn’t make any moves. It’s legitimately interesting that more than two-thirds of fans are unhappy that the Giants sat out the trade deadline.

In our polls leading up to the trade deadline, fans were roughly split down the middle on whether they wanted the team to make trades.

People Also Search

• Why the Giants didn't make any trades before NFL deadline
• Why Joe Schoen, Giants stayed silent at the NFL trade deadline
• Why New York Giants Are Losers at Trade Deadline
• Giants' biggest failures were quietly confirmed by trade deadline silence
• 2 winners (and 4 losers) from Giants' trade deadline snoozefest
• Giants' lack of moves at the NFL trade deadline speaks volumes about ...
• Why Giants didn't become big buyers or sellers ahead of trade deadline ...
• 3 Takeaways From Giants' Silent Trade Deadline
• Giants were not buyers or sellers at NFL trade deadline. So now what?
• New York Giants fans unhappy with NFL trade deadline inactivity