University of Kwazulu-Natal

Why Joe Schoen Giants Stayed Silent At The Nfl Trade Deadline

Bonisiwe Shabane
-
why joe schoen giants stayed silent at the nfl trade deadline

GM Joe Schoen didn't make any deals ahead of Tuesday's NFL trade deadline. Ishika Samant / Getty Images Despite all the chatter, all was quiet in East Rutherford, N.J., as the NFL’s 4 p.m. ET trade deadline passed Tuesday without any activity from the New York Giants, who were neither buyers nor sellers. Only three weeks ago, standing pat seemed unlikely, as the Giants were coming off a huge prime-time win over the division rival Philadelphia Eagles and seemed poised to turn a corner behind the heroics... After losing star receiver Malik Nabers for the season to an ACL tear, rumors swirled about adding a top receiving talent to help Dart’s development, especially after the victory over Philadelphia moved the Giants...

They carried that momentum of that victory into Denver and should have come away with a win. Instead, they suffered a historic meltdown, allowing the Broncos to pull off a miraculous comeback that put the kibosh on the Giants’ good vibes. Two dismal showings, along with a season-ending injury for top rusher Cam Skattebo, have followed. The Giants are now amid a three-game losing streak and have dropped to 2-7 for the third season in a row. And here's the recording to yesterday's live room, where I continued my streak of saying I'm not that fired up … and then 20 minutes later found myself launching into an eight-minute rant on... Tuesday’s NFL trade deadline came and went without the New York Giants making a single move.

At 2-7 and spiraling toward another lost season, Big Blue’s silence stood in stark contrast to their MetLife Stadium co-tenants, the New York Jets, who aggressively reshaped their roster. But sometimes inaction speaks louder than any transaction — and what the Giants didn’t do reveals plenty about the franchise’s uncertain direction. Unless the team engineers a miraculous turnaround over the final eight games, head coach Brian Daboll will likely be dismissed. General manager Joe Schoen’s future, however, remains murkier. The decision to stand pat rather than trade assets like wide receiver Jalin Hyatt or offensive lineman Evan Neal for future draft capital suggests the 46-year-old general manager isn’t a lock to return next... If co-owners John Mara and Steve Tisch had given him a vote of confidence, why wouldn’t he maximize assets for the 2026 NFL Draft?

Perhaps ownership doesn’t want Schoen making long-term roster decisions if his job security remains in question. Schoen and Daboll’s working relationship dates to their Buffalo Bills tenure from 2018-2021, and Schoen hired Daboll as New York’s head coach in January 2022. The belief has been their fates are intertwined. Their collective inaction at the deadline only reinforces that connection. Time crunch?Get all your NFL news here in just 60 words For the New York Giants, the 2025 trade deadline came and went with the same silence that’s defined their season and front office.

Despite sitting at 2–7 and dealing with injuries to key players like Cam Skattebo, GM Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll showed no proactiveness on D-day to improve. Not as buyers, and not even as sellers. And that’s exactly what sent Giants fans over the edge. After nearly four years of mediocrity, the patience has evaporated. Since Schoen took over in 2022, the Giants have only won 20 games, while losing 39, which means they win just one out of every three games. Moreover, the club’s defensive front remains a glaring weakness, ranking in the bottom six in run defense for the fourth straight year, while the entire roster continues to lack foundational players outside of Jaxson...

Giants are ranked 32nd in run defense through 2 weeks. The trade deadline has come and gone for Big Blue, and it was all quiet out of 1925 Giants Drive. Rumors flew for weeks about the New York Giants potentially being in trade talks with teams like the Cleveland Browns, Miami Dolphins, and New Orleans Saints for one of their receivers, but nothing ever... General manager Joe Schoen worked the phones, but when the deals came out about compensation, the price tags were simply too high. One name that kept flashing was Dolphins wide receiver Jaylen Waddle. A potential deal for Waddle looked close to happening one day and completely dead the next.

Ultimately, the Giants had no choice but to walk away from any negotiation involving the 27-year-old wideout. Waddle would’ve been an instant No. 1 target for Jaxson Dart and would’ve paired perfectly with Malik Nabers once he returns from injury next season. Waddle is under contract until 2029, so the Giants wouldn’t have had to worry about him being a midseason rental who could walk in free agency. Getting someone like him while Dart, Nabers, and others are still on rookie deals would’ve been a smart, win-now move for an offense that’s shown surprising signs of life over the past month. For Schoen and Co., once they saw the compensation being given up for other receivers — and were told the base asking price for Waddle was at least a first-round pick — they backed...

At 2-7, facing another lost year, it’s hard to blame them. The Giants are currently projected to land another top-five pick, and with a loaded wide receiver class in the 2026 NFL Draft, reinforcements may come cheaper. The New York Giants have not made any trades yet on NFL trade deadline day. Some fans want to see players like Jalin Hyatt, Evan Neal, Deonte Banks, Dexter Lawrence, and others traded. Giants general manager Joe Schoen has not been active during this deadline as of yet. However, the New York Jets have made several shocking trades during Tuesday’s NFL trade deadline day.

Giants fans are upset that this team is not making any moves. They are questioning Schoen because they have a 2-7 record once again and the Giants need to be sellers instead of staying pat at the NFL trade deadline. Many Giants fans have been paying close attention to what the Dallas Cowboys, the Philadelphia Eagles, and the Jets have been doing during the NFL trade deadline. New York fans are furious that Schoen has not made any moves to trade away players and get more draft capital for the 2026 NFL Draft and other future drafts as well. This is what some Giants fans said about Schoen sitting with his hands tied during the deadline on Twitter: — Craig 🌙 (@KraigNJ66) November 4, 2025

The New York Giants had a quiet trade deadline, but it wasn’t for lack of effort. General manager Joe Schoen “feverishly worked the phones from all angles in recent weeks,” Ryan Dunleavy of the New York Post writes. Schoen called about some “big players,” Jordan Raanan of ESPN adds, but he wasn’t in position to surrender significant draft capital. At 2-7 and all but eliminated from playoff contention, the Giants were only going to add if it meant acquiring a player (or players) under control beyond this season, per Dunleavy. Having lost No. 1 wide receiver Malik Nabers to a season-ending ACL tear in Week 4, the Giants were reportedly “big-game hunting” at the position in mid-October.

However, that was before the Giants dropped three straight games and drifted out of the postseason race. It’s unclear if the Giants were in on any receivers on Tuesday, but Jakobi Meyers and Rashid Shaheed were the only proven wideouts who ended up on the move. As pending free agents, neither player was a fit for the Giants. The Dolphins listened to offers Jaylen Waddle, who’s under control through 2028, but nobody would meet their asking price of a first-round pick and more. With the deadline having come and gone with no receiver addition, the Giants will head into the offseason with Nabers and Darius Slayton as their top options for 2026. Otherwise, New York doesn’t have any reliable wideouts under contract for next year.

As the Giants’ leading receiver this year, soon-to-be free agent Wan’Dale Robinson has formed a rapport with rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart. Robinson would like to remain a Giant, but if the team don’t re-sign him, it could find a replacement via the draft, trade, or free agency. That’ll be up to the GM to decide, whether it’s Schoen or someone else. New York Giants fans sarcastically remarked that general manager Joe Schoen "forgot to charge his phone" after watching their team do no business across Tuesday's trade deadline. Expectations were already low when head coach Brian Daboll suggested that the franchise would not be active in the lead-up to the deadline, yet fans were still hoping for some kind of movement given... Furthermore, Daboll had made his feelings clear on his side's defensive struggles in the aftermath of Sunday's 24-34 defeat to the San Francisco 49ers, yet ultimately, the Giants did nothing.

To make matters worse, their city rivals, the New York Jets, went all out. While they may have traded two-time All-Pro cornerback Sauce Gardner to the Indianapolis Colts, the Jets received two first-round picks and wide receiver Adonai Mitchell in return. They also swapped three-time Pro Bowl defensive tackle Quinnen Williams to the Dallas Cowboys for a first-round pick in 2027, along with a second-round pick in 2026 and defensive tackle Mazi Smith, taking the... Tuesday’s NFL trade deadline came and went without the New York Giants making a single move. At 2-7 and spiraling toward another lost season, Big Blue’s silence stood in stark contrast to their MetLife Stadium co-tenants, the New York Jets, who aggressively reshaped their roster. But sometimes inaction speaks louder than any transaction — and what the Giants didn’t do reveals plenty about the franchise’s uncertain direction.

Unless the team engineers a miraculous turnaround over the final eight games, head coach Brian Daboll will likely be dismissed. General manager Joe Schoen’s future, however, remains murkier. The decision to stand pat rather than trade assets like wide receiver Jalin Hyatt or offensive lineman Evan Neal for future draft capital suggests the 46-year-old general manager isn’t a lock to return next... If co-owners John Mara and Steve Tisch had given him a vote of confidence, why wouldn’t he maximize assets for the 2026 NFL Draft? Perhaps ownership doesn’t want Schoen making long-term roster decisions if his job security remains in question. Schoen and Daboll’s working relationship dates to their Buffalo Bills tenure from 2018-2021, and Schoen hired Daboll as New York’s head coach in January 2022.

The belief has been their fates are intertwined. Their collective inaction at the deadline only reinforces that connection. The New York Giants were seen as one of the top franchises to sell key pieces at this year's deadline. At 2-7, there's little to no hope for them to find a way into the playoff race or stay remotely competitive in the second half of the season. However, when the 4 p.m. trade deadline hit on Tuesday, New York did not move any players out which came as a surprise league-wide.

Wide receiver Darius Slayton and linebacker Azeez Ojulari were general manager Joe Schoen's top bargaining chips since they're both pending free agents at the end of the year. It would've been good business to get something back for them ahead of the 2025 Draft. According to The Athletic's Dianna Russini ($), the Giants' general manager set Ojulari's asking price high and teams refused to pay it. This can only be interpreted as New York's way of saying it doesn't want to break up its league-leading defense in sacks. The Giants are still without first-round linebacker Kayvon Thibodeaux, who is on IR after undergoing wrist surgery almost a month ago.

People Also Search

GM Joe Schoen Didn't Make Any Deals Ahead Of Tuesday's

GM Joe Schoen didn't make any deals ahead of Tuesday's NFL trade deadline. Ishika Samant / Getty Images Despite all the chatter, all was quiet in East Rutherford, N.J., as the NFL’s 4 p.m. ET trade deadline passed Tuesday without any activity from the New York Giants, who were neither buyers nor sellers. Only three weeks ago, standing pat seemed unlikely, as the Giants were coming off a huge prime...

They Carried That Momentum Of That Victory Into Denver And

They carried that momentum of that victory into Denver and should have come away with a win. Instead, they suffered a historic meltdown, allowing the Broncos to pull off a miraculous comeback that put the kibosh on the Giants’ good vibes. Two dismal showings, along with a season-ending injury for top rusher Cam Skattebo, have followed. The Giants are now amid a three-game losing streak and have dr...

At 2-7 And Spiraling Toward Another Lost Season, Big Blue’s

At 2-7 and spiraling toward another lost season, Big Blue’s silence stood in stark contrast to their MetLife Stadium co-tenants, the New York Jets, who aggressively reshaped their roster. But sometimes inaction speaks louder than any transaction — and what the Giants didn’t do reveals plenty about the franchise’s uncertain direction. Unless the team engineers a miraculous turnaround over the final...

Perhaps Ownership Doesn’t Want Schoen Making Long-term Roster Decisions If

Perhaps ownership doesn’t want Schoen making long-term roster decisions if his job security remains in question. Schoen and Daboll’s working relationship dates to their Buffalo Bills tenure from 2018-2021, and Schoen hired Daboll as New York’s head coach in January 2022. The belief has been their fates are intertwined. Their collective inaction at the deadline only reinforces that connection. Time...

Despite Sitting At 2–7 And Dealing With Injuries To Key

Despite sitting at 2–7 and dealing with injuries to key players like Cam Skattebo, GM Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll showed no proactiveness on D-day to improve. Not as buyers, and not even as sellers. And that’s exactly what sent Giants fans over the edge. After nearly four years of mediocrity, the patience has evaporated. Since Schoen took over in 2022, the Giants have only won 20 games,...