Alex Cora S Puzzling Decision Leaves Red Sox Fans Frustrated After

Bonisiwe Shabane

-Nov 18, 2025, 7:15 AM

alex cora s puzzling decision leaves red sox fans frustrated after

When the Red Sox decided to double down on their $140 million gamble, fans expected fireworks, not a slow, painful fizzle. Yet again, Alex Cora lit the fuse on a high-stakes move that blew up in all the wrong ways. Boston faithful, never shy with their opinions, didn’t hold back as their skipper’s calculated risk turned into another chapter of head-scratching choices and underwhelming returns. Are the Boston Red Sox doing well in the league? Some would say yes, some would say no. Do they need a backup player to fill in spots?

Yes, they do. What they don’t need is a $140 million player named Trevor Story to be back in the lineup. Trevor Story has been underperforming for quite some time now, and the fans are not happy with Cora’s decision to leave him on the team. For their game against the Milwaukee Brewers, Alex Cora decided to use some new players in the absence of Alex Bregman. The lineup reported by Tyler Milliken is, “Jarren Duran LF. Rafael Devers DH… Trevor Story SS.

Abraham Toro 1 B. David Hamilton 2B.” While the rest of the lineup is okay, people saw Trevor Story’s name and decided that Alex Cora might not be making the right decision. With a .220 batting average and an OPS barely scraping .589, Story’s not doing too well. His 64 strikeouts this season don’t speak too well for him. 1. Jarren Duran LF 2.

Rafael Devers DH 3. Carlos Narváez C 4. Kristian Campbell CF 5. Wilyer Abreu RF 6. Marcelo Mayer 3B 7. Trevor Story SS 8.

Abraham Toro 1B 9. David Hamilton 2B The Boston Red Sox may have come into Monday night’s matchup against the Tampa Bay Rays with renewed momentum, but they left the field with frustration and their manager, Alex Cora, watching the end... Try PFSN's FREE fantasy baseball trade analyzer to help you make the best decisions for your fantasy teams! The Red Sox lost 10-8 in 11 innings after overcoming an early 3-0 deficit and forcing the game into extra innings, but how it ended had players, fans, and social media talking. Boston was threatening in the bottom of the eleventh when Romy Gonzalez took a close pitch on a full count that seemed to be ball four.

It was referred to as strike three instead. Home plate umpire Junior Valentine, who had already garnered criticism for a strike zone that many felt lacked consistency, swiftly removed Cora when he stormed out of the dugout. Alex Cora being tossed for the second time this season. The Boston Red Sox just had a heart-breaking loss last night to the Baltimore Orioles, losing 4-3. The Sox lost back to back games at home, where they were 16-3 before the series. This also was the first home series loss since late June.

Sox manager Alex Cora held a post-game press conference to talk about the loss, and explain their grievous mistake: They had Nate Eaton pinch run as the game-tying run in extra innings on third,... MORE: Red Sox predicted to reunite with four-time All-star through waivers to upgrade bullpen for playoff push ““That’s an impact arm in CF. We prepare before the series and we decide who we’re gonna challenge and not, so we didn’t challenge him…We prepared before the series, and that’s an impact arm, and we decided not to challenge... Cora stuck with the answer, even after follow ups. The Orioles had Colton Cowser in center field, who’s in the 95th percentile for arm strength, which means he has one of the best arms in the game.

The 2025 Boston Red Sox have reached a new low. After suffering another one-run loss on Tuesday night at Fenway Park to the Los Angeles Angels, Boston has a 29-34 record on the season. That makes the Red Sox 10 games back of the American League East-leading New York Yankees. Only the Baltimore Orioles, Athletics, and Chicago White Sox have worse records in the entire AL. For a team as talented on paper as the Red Sox, the record is inexcusable. Though there are 99 games left to play, fans of the team cannot recall a more frustrating season.

A lot of the angst stems from the fact that exactly half of Boston’s 34 losses have been decided by one run. That’s right — the Red Sox have already lost 17 one-run games in 2025. Another insanity-inducing trait of this Boston club is its inability to defend. The Red Sox made three further errors on Tuesday night versus the Angels, increasing their AL-leading total to 53 errors on the season. This was supposed to be a big year for the Boston Red Sox after a terrific offseason, but it isn't off to a good start. The Red Sox are now 27-31 after getting swept by the Milwaukee Brewers.

Boston lost on a walk-off on Wednesday for the second day in a row, and it all happened because of an error. Things aren't looking good for manager Alex Cora and Boston after this 6-5 loss. The Red Sox went up 5-4 in the 10th inning, but the Brewers tied the game on a throwing error by second baseman Kristian Campbell. “First and third, you've just got to read it, right? If it's a hard hit ground ball to you that we have a chance to get the guy at the plate, we go to the plate,” Alex Cora said after the game. “But that one was, like, it wasn't hit hard, so turn the double play and move on to the next.”

There were no outs in the inning, so a double play would not have ended the game. However, the Red Sox probably would've been able to force another inning. “We didn't play well today, the score was the score, but we walked the lead-off guy, we didn't cover first, we drop a fly ball in left,” Cora added. “We got thrown out at third. We made the play at the end. So, yeah, I mean, the score will say that it was a good baseball game, but we didn't play well today.”

It's not exactly a secret that the Boston Red Sox haven't been playing their best baseball lately. A promising stretch before the All-Star break has turned into fighting for life back at .500 with 22 games remaining. There are a few common denominators that have cost the Sox games during their postseason push. Rough relief pitching and high strikeout totals for Boston are factors, but Alex Cora's managerial philosophy seems to have changed in recent weeks. The skipper managed a great first half for the Red Sox, but the second half has raised questions about his methods. Cora opted to pull Cooper Criswell from a tight matchup against the Tigers while he was throwing a perfect game.

Rich Hill entered the game in the fifth inning, which led to two runs scoring, which became the death knell for the Sox as they lost both the game and the series. However, what was overshadowed by the Criswell decision was a defensive deployment that Cora made. Danny Jansen pinch hit for Wilyer Abreu during the game and remained in the game behind the plate. Needing an outfielder, Cora chose Connor Wong. Yes, that Connor Wong. Masataka Yoshida has been one of Boston's best hitters since the All-Star break🔗 https://t.co/UT6z9Dho6o

June 23, 2025, 5:28pm EST 154 • By Swati Bhatia What should have been a momentum-shifting moment for the Boston Red Sox quickly turned into controversy and chaos during Sunday’s rubber match against the San Francisco Giants. Trailing 8-5 in the top of the eighth inning, Jarren Duran ripped a leadoff double down the right-field line. He slid headfirst into second base, appearing to beat the tag with a clean dive and maintain contact with the bag. But second-base umpire Doug Eddings saw it differently, ruling Duran out for briefly coming off the base. Boston manager Alex Cora quickly challenged the call.

Replay footage clearly showed Duran’s hand on the bag before Willy Adames applied the tag again. Yet, despite the apparent evidence, the call stood after a Crew Chief Review. Jarren Duran and Alex Cora have both been ejected after replay upheld the call that Willy Adames tagged Duran out at second base pic.twitter.com/iu0FZRWB5S How Red Sox manager Alex Cora explained costly decision vs. Orioles originally appeared on NBC Sports Boston The Red Sox concocted a plan before their series against the Orioles and stuck to it, manager Alex Cora said after a frustrating 4-3 loss at Fenway Park on Tuesday night.

Red Sox pinch-runner Nate Eaton stood at third base as Boston trailed Baltimore 4-3 with one out in the 11th inning. With the speedy Eaton representing the game-tying run, Roman Anthony hit a 265-foot fly ball to center field. Fans watching at home surely figured it would at least turn into a play at the plate, and perhaps another clutch RBI for the rookie slugger. However, just after Orioles outfielder Colton Cowser hauled in the pop fly and unleashed an off-line throw which ended up between third base and home plate, Eaton returned to the bag after pump-faking a... Alex Bregman then stepped into the batter’s box and popped up to shortstop for the game’s final out. Cora explained the questionable decision after Boston’s third consecutive loss.

People Also Search

When The Red Sox Decided To Double Down On Their

Yes, They Do. What They Don’t Need Is A $140

Abraham Toro 1 B. David Hamilton 2B.” While The Rest

Rafael Devers DH 3. Carlos Narváez C 4. Kristian Campbell

Rafael Devers DH 3. Carlos Narváez C 4. Kristian Campbell CF 5. Wilyer Abreu RF 6. Marcelo Mayer 3B 7. Trevor Story SS 8.