Ego Of These Umpires Will Be Why They Will Be Replaced Red Sox Fans

Bonisiwe Shabane

-Nov 18, 2025, 8:45 AM

ego of these umpires will be why they will be replaced red sox fans

June 23, 2025, 5:28pm EST 154 • By Swati Bhatia What should have been a momentum-shifting moment for the Boston Red Sox quickly turned into controversy and chaos during Sunday’s rubber match against the San Francisco Giants. Trailing 8-5 in the top of the eighth inning, Jarren Duran ripped a leadoff double down the right-field line. He slid headfirst into second base, appearing to beat the tag with a clean dive and maintain contact with the bag. But second-base umpire Doug Eddings saw it differently, ruling Duran out for briefly coming off the base. Boston manager Alex Cora quickly challenged the call.

Replay footage clearly showed Duran’s hand on the bag before Willy Adames applied the tag again. Yet, despite the apparent evidence, the call stood after a Crew Chief Review. Jarren Duran and Alex Cora have both been ejected after replay upheld the call that Willy Adames tagged Duran out at second base pic.twitter.com/iu0FZRWB5S Boston Red Sox manager Alex Cora and outfielder Jarren Duran were ejected from Sunday's game against the San Francisco Giants for arguing a controversial ruling made by the umpiring crew. The incident occurred during the eighth inning when Duran laced a ball into right field and attempted to stretch the hit into a double. Duran beat the throw to second base, but he was unable to keep his hand on the bag when sliding.

As his fingertips slipped off the bag, Giants shortstop Willy Adams tried to tag him out, resulting in a replay review. Despite the replay showing convincing evidence that Duran had gotten his hand back on the bag before the tag was applied, the umpires ruled him out. Jarren Duran and Alex Cora have both been tossed after replay ruled that Duran was tagged out at second by Willy Adames pic.twitter.com/skzZeI1mmQ Duran appeared to say something while walking past second base umpire Doug Eddings, who proceeded to eject him from the game. Cora then came out to air his grievances and was also ejected. Another day, another blown call, and MLB finds itself under the microscope yet again.

It now looks like this season has been anything but smooth when it comes to officiating, with a string of high-profile errors casting a long shadow over the game. Well, this time the Red Sox’s pitcher, Walker Buehler, paid a high price for the consequences of the blown-up call. The latest controversy erupted during the Mets-Red Sox clash, where a clearly missed call ignited tempers on both sides. Now you know what would be followed. Yes, a swift fallout. Two ejections, a frustrated dugout, and a fan base left shaking its head in disbelief.

It’s become a familiar script, one that has fans wondering. So, what will it take to bring meaningful change to MLB umpiring? As the season rolls on, the pressure for accountability and reform is only growing louder. Onlookers and analysts alike have begun to ask the uncomfortable question. Is this just a rough patch, or is the system fundamentally broken? "get back on the mound" pic.twitter.com/R3B3T76fSN

— Red Sox Stats (@redsoxstats) May 20, 2025 If you tuned into Sunday’s Red Sox-Giants game hoping for a clean finish, you got drama instead—and not the good kind. We’re talking about a full-on meltdown in the eighth inning, with Boston’s Jarren Duran and manager Alex Cora both getting tossed after a controversial replay decision that left just about everyone—fans and players scratching... So here’s what happened: Jarren Duran smacks a rocket into right field. He’s thinking two all the way—hustling, sliding, playing with that trademark energy we’ve come to expect. He beats the throw to second, but as he slides in, his hand just momentarily lifts off the bag.

Like, we’re talking split-second stuff here. Giants shortstop Willy Adames is right there, glove down, hoping to catch Duran in that blink-of-an-eye moment of vulnerability. That’s when the umpires call for a review. If you saw the replay—and millions did—it sure looked like Duran managed to get his hand back on the bag before the tag was fully applied. But the umpiring crew, after the kind of deliberation that usually ends with a birthday candle wish, ruled him out. And just like that, the tension exploded.

Duran didn’t keep quiet. As he walked past second base umpire Doug Eddings, he said something—we don’t know exactly what—but it was enough for Eddings to send him packing. That’s when Alex Cora came storming out of the dugout, likely echoing what half of Red Sox Nation was yelling at their screens. And yep, he got ejected alongside Duran. Jarren Duran and Alex Cora have both been tossed after replay ruled that Duran was tagged out at second by Willy Adames pic.twitter.com/skzZeI1mmQ The Boston Red Sox managed to hold on to the lead on Tuesday night thanks in large part to their bullpen, which went nearly seven innings and didn't give up a run to the...

Boston was put in this position thanks to an umpire ejection of Walker Buehler, who stepped off the mound to argue balls and strikes with home-plate umpire Mike Estabrook. As crew chief Laz Diaz said after the game, stepping off the mound was ultimately what cost Buehler, and eventually his manager Alex Cora. One call in question was to Juan Soto, who was walked on what should've been strike one. Red Sox beat reporter Ian Browne highlighted this. Buehler, unsurprisingly, wasn't thrilled with the call. Then, Francisco Lindor leaned into a pitch that eventually hit him in the foot.

Lindor was still gifted a walk. Buehler stepped off the mound to scream at Estabrook, who had a quick hook as a result. “It’s right down the [expletive] middle,” Buehler said from the mound. “Get back on the mound!” Estabrook shouted back at Buehler. The Red Sox pitcher did not abide, and Estabrook wasn't up for a conversation. For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the discord to get the inside scoop...

Written by sports fans for sports fans since 2007, Total Pro Sports covers breaking news both on and off the field and across the sports landscape. TPS readers can stay up to date with stories on trends, in-depth analysis, controversies, and more. What should have been a momentum-shifting moment for the Boston Red Sox quickly turned into controversy and chaos during Sunday’s rubber match against the San Francisco Giants. Trailing 8-5 in the top of the eighth inning, Jarren Duran ripped a leadoff double down the right-field line. He slid headfirst into second base, appearing to beat the tag with a clean dive and maintain contact with the bag. But second-base umpire Doug Eddings saw it differently, ruling Duran out for briefly coming off the base.

Boston manager Alex Cora quickly challenged the call. Replay footage clearly showed Duran’s hand on the bag before Willy Adames applied the tag again. Yet, despite the apparent evidence, the call stood after a Crew Chief Review. The Giants went on to secure a 9-5 win, taking the series and sending the Red Sox home empty-handed. Red Sox fans were livid on social media, not only over the blown call but the stubbornness of the review system. There’s a little extra spark when the Boston Red Sox and Texas Rangers play one another, sometimes leading to arguments with the umpires – remember Texas Manager Bruce Bochy getting tossed for arguable calls...

That familiar tension bubbled up dramatically this weekend. It’s a reminder that close calls in tight games often get heavily scrutinized. And when the fate of a match hangs in the balance, as Saturday night’s did, every decision made behind home plate takes on an outsized significance, sometimes shifting momentum — even the final result. The March 29 game between the Red Sox and Rangers was a thriller from the very first pitch. Adolis García’s two-run double helped the Rangers take an early lead, but Red Sox rookie Kristian Campbell helped tie the game with his first career homer. García wasn’t done, launching a go-ahead solo home run before Texas tacked on another run.

Boston fought back, getting within 4-3 in the eighth, but could not finish the job, leaving 10 runners on base. That one-run margin quickly became a focus of controversy beyond the Red Sox’s offensive woes. Immediately after the final out, the focus turned toward home plate umpire Adam Hamari. “UmpScorecards” posted an analysis of Hamari’s call. It wasn’t simply a practice report: It offered data that pointed to serious problems throughout the night. That fired up an argument online, as many believed the umpiring could have been a determining factor.

When the strike zone starts to resemble abstract art and critical calls swing wilder than a 3–0 count fastball, you know something’s gone terribly wrong behind the plate. Toronto Blue Jays fans aren’t just upset—they’re clamoring for fairness and consistency. As one umpire’s name echoes louder than the final score, the outrage is no longer about a missed call. It’s about a game being hijacked by a man with a mask and a mic. The first name that we think of when it comes to bad umpiring is Angel Hernandez, but now it has a new name. The new name is Manny Gonzalez, and it is becoming the new definition of “bad umpiring.” After the Blue Jays vs Red Sox game, it became evidently clear why MLB needs ABS, and they...

It was posted by the Umpire Auditor through his X handle about this incident and also showed his badly it impacted the game. He wrote “Umpire Manny Gonzalez missed 14 calls in the Red Sox Blue Jays game. 12 of them went against the Blue Jays.” It might be possibly unrelated, but these calls did have an impact on the Blue Jays, who lost the game by just one run. Several players, including Bo Bichette and Andres Gimenez, were visibly angry, but no one was ejected during the game. Even the Blue Jays manager, John Schneider said, “It’s tough to battle nine hitters and an umpire.” But this isn’t Gonzalez’s first instance of making such poor calls.

Umpire Manny Gonzalez missed 14 calls in the Red Sox Blue Jays game. 12 of them went against the Blue Jays.

Ego Of These Umpires Will Be Why They Will Be Replaced Red Sox Fans

People Also Search

June 23, 2025, 5:28pm EST 154 • By Swati Bhatia

Replay Footage Clearly Showed Duran’s Hand On The Bag Before

As His Fingertips Slipped Off The Bag, Giants Shortstop Willy

It Now Looks Like This Season Has Been Anything But

It’s Become A Familiar Script, One That Has Fans Wondering.