Utah County Faces Millions For Tyler Robinson Murder Defense Costs

Bonisiwe Shabane

-Nov 18, 2025, 2:24 AM

utah county faces millions for tyler robinson murder defense costs

Commissioner Amelia Powers Gardner discusses the legal, financial, and emotional pressures Utah County faces as the Charlie Kirk murder case moves toward trial. Utah County leaders are navigating mounting costs, national media attention and public frustration over the county’s obligation to pay for defense attorneys in the case against Tyler Robinson, the man accused of killing Turning... Commissioner Amelia Powers Gardner, one of three elected county commissioners who oversee policy, operations and finances, said Utah County has already spent "just over a quarter of a million dollars" on the case, a... "Under the Constitution, we have a right to a competent defense," Powers Gardner said. "It is imperative that if we want to have a society that we believe in justice, that justice needs to be fair and equal." She said she’s heard from constituents who are frustrated that taxpayer dollars will fund his defense.

Still, she emphasized the county’s constitutional duty and the financial wisdom of ensuring a fair trial, especially in a potential death-penalty case. The man accused of killing Charlie Kirk will have an experienced team of lawyers representing him in the high-profile capital murder case. Utah County hired three attorneys to represent Tyler James Robinson after 4th District Court Judge Tony Graf found he doesn’t have the financial means to pay a lawyer. Salt Lake City attorney Kathryn N. Nester is the lead counsel, while Michael N. Burt and Richard G.

Novak, both of California, are co-counsel. All have substantial experience in death penalty cases. Robinson allegedly shot Kirk with a high-powered rifle from a rooftop as the conservative political activist spoke at an outdoor event at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10. At the urging of his parents and a family friend, Robinson turned himself in to police near his home in Washington County, Utah, the next day. Authorities announced the arrest in a press conference Sept.

12. Robinson, 22, is charged with aggravated murder and six other crimes in connection with the fatal shooting. Utah County Attorney Jeff Gray is pursuing the death penalty. (Laura Seitz | Pool) Defense attorneys Richard G. Novak, left, Michael N. Burt, and Kathryn Nester, who are representing Tyler Robinson, the man accused of killing Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University, appear at a waiver hearing in 4th District Court in Provo on Monday, Sept.

29, 2025. Utah County officials say the increased attention and public scrutiny of the death penalty case against Tyler Robinson, the 22-year-old accused of fatally shooting conservative activist Charlie Kirk, contributed to their decision to pay... Robinson is accused of shooting Kirk, the controversial Turning Point USA founder, on Sept. 10 while Kirk was speaking in front of thousands at Utah Valley University. Utah County prosecutors charged him with seven counts, including aggravated murder, and he faces a potential death sentence if he’s convicted. (Left: Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune; right: Utah County Sheriff's Office) Kathryn Nester, left, the defense attorney assigned to represent Tyler Robinson has filed a motion arguing that Robinson should be allowed...

Robinson has been charged with aggravated murder in the Sept. 10, 2025, shooting death of political activist Charlie Kirk. A judge has found that Robinson can’t afford his own attorney — so Utah County is now constitutionally required to foot the bill for his defense. Officials have estimated it could cost more than $1 million to fund both the prosecution and the defense. Commissioner Amelia Powers Gardner discusses the legal, financial, and emotional pressures Utah County faces as the Charlie Kirk murder case moves toward trial. Utah County leaders are navigating mounting costs, national media attention and public frustration over the county’s obligation to pay for defense attorneys in the case against Tyler Robinson, the man accused of killing Turning...

Commissioner Amelia Powers Gardner, one of three elected county commissioners who oversee policy, operations and finances, said Utah County has already spent "just over a quarter of a million dollars" on the case, a... "Under the Constitution, we have a right to a competent defense," Powers Gardner said. "It is imperative that if we want to have a society that we believe in justice, that justice needs to be fair and equal." She said she’s heard from constituents who are frustrated that taxpayer dollars will fund his defense. Still, she emphasized the county’s constitutional duty and the financial wisdom of ensuring a fair trial, especially in a potential death-penalty case. Utah County leaders are now busy navigating increasing costs, public frustration and media attention over the United States’ obligation to pay for defense attorneys in the case against Tyler Robinson, Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin.

Commissioner Amelia Powers Gardner, one of three elected county commissioners who oversee policy, operations and finances, said that Utah County has already had to spend "just over a quarter of a million dollars" on... The figure is expected to double by the year’s end, and might even reach around $5 million over the next year and a half, she added. "Under the Constitution, we have a right to a competent defense," Powers Gardner said, per the outlet. "It is imperative that if we want to have a society that we believe in justice, that justice needs to be fair and equal." Powers Gardner said that she has heard from frustrated constituents... However, she stressed the county’s duty to ensure a fair trial, especially in a case that might result in the death penalty. Powers Gardner said that she is working to keep the community united after the tragedy.

"My job is also to be a leader for my community, and that’s what I have focused on," she said. "You have to keep in mind, not everybody who was traumatized that day was a Charlie Kirk supporter. Utah County leaders are now busy navigating increasing costs, public frustration and media attention over the United States’ obligation to pay for defense attorneys in the case against Tyler Robinson, Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin. Commissioner Amelia Powers Gardner, one of three elected county commissioners who oversee policy, operations and finances, said that Utah County has already had to spend "just over a quarter of a million dollars" on... The figure is expected to double by the year’s end, and might even reach around $5 million over the next year and a half, she added. "Under the Constitution, we have a right to a competent defense," Powers Gardner said, per the outlet.

"It is imperative that if we want to have a society that we believe in justice, that justice needs to be fair and equal." Powers Gardner said that she has heard from frustrated constituents that taxpayer dollars will fund his defense. However, she stressed the county’s duty to ensure a fair trial, especially in a case that might result in the death penalty. Powers Gardner said that she is working to keep the community united after the tragedy. "My job is also to be a leader for my community, and that’s what I have focused on," she said. "You have to keep in mind, not everybody who was traumatized that day was a Charlie Kirk supporter.

There were hundreds of people there that were protesting at that event and were just as traumatized that they saw a father and husband murdered." Read More | Tulsi Gabbard holds back tears as she honors Charlie Kirk, ‘The time that we have in this world is temporary’ | Video Utah County is dealing with a significant financial burden as it prepares for a potential death penalty case against Tyler Robinson, the man accused of killing Charlie Kirk. The county’s commissioners have already spent over $250,000 on the case and anticipate costs to double, potentially reaching $5 million. Amelia Powers Gardner, one of three elected county commissioners overseeing policy, operations, and finances, said the county has already spent “just over a quarter of a million dollars” and expects the cost to double... She emphasized that the Constitution guarantees the right to a competent defense, underscoring the importance of fair and equal justice.

Despite public frustration over taxpayers funding the case, she maintained that the financial wisdom of ensuring a fair trial outweighs the costs, even in a death-penalty case. The case has attracted national media attention and has led to a lack of willing defense attorneys, as many local attorneys declined the county’s standard contract due to the emotionally and politically charged nature... The county attempted to join Utah’s Aggravated Murder Defense Fund in 2024, but was denied, leaving only $31 in the reserve for such cases. The county is also facing new operational and security challenges, including the use of armored vehicles for transporting Robinson, clearing buildings around the courthouse, and implementing active-shooter training. Powers Gardner noted that the county has already used $250,000 in the past six weeks and expects costs to continue rising. She also credited Gov.

Spencer Cox for being “incredibly supportive” and personally engaged in the days following the shooting. The prosecution is preparing for a potential death penalty case against Robinson, who faces the top charge of aggravated murder. Prosecutors allege that Robinson used his grandfather’s Mauser .30-06 rifle to climb onto a campus rooftop and shoot Kirk once in the neck during a speaking event at Utah Valley University on September 10. The case highlights the complex interplay between justice, public safety, and financial responsibility, as Utah County navigates the consequences of a high-profile murder and the legal obligations inherent in such cases. PROVO — Utah County leaders on Thursday further outlined how they planned to pay for the legal costs associated with the prosecution of Charlie Kirk’s accused killer in a capital murder case. On Wednesday, the Utah County Commission approved $1 million in additional staffing as it aimed to pay for both the prosecution of 22-year-old Tyler Robinson — who is charged with aggravated murder — and...

County officials said the money would go toward adding two full-time deputy county attorney positions and two full-time paralegal positions. The county also announced it had retained experienced trial lawyer Kathryn Nester as Robinson’s defense attorney. On Thursday, County Commissioner Skyler Beltran said the new county attorney hires likely would be needed in the next two to three years to help deal with a growing caseload anyway, but the county... Although Utah County approved $1 million in initial funding for Tyler Robinson's case defence, criminal defence lawyers predict that the costs will go higher As the trial of Tyler Robinson—the alleged killer of conservative activist and Donald Trump ally Charlie Kirk—continues, criminal lawyers have warned that the defence fees—taken from Utah taxpayers' money—may go "north of $10 million". Kirk was killed by a single gunshot wound to the neck while speaking at the Utah Valley University on September 10.

Although Utah County approved $1 million in initial funding for Tyler Robinson's case defence, criminal defence lawyers told Fox News Digital that the costs will go higher, primarily because Robinson was facing a potential... ALSO READ | How Tyler Robinson could get away with Charlie Kirk's murder if prosecution messes up the timeline

Utah County Faces Millions For Tyler Robinson Murder Defense Costs

People Also Search

Commissioner Amelia Powers Gardner Discusses The Legal, Financial, And Emotional

Still, She Emphasized The County’s Constitutional Duty And The Financial

Novak, Both Of California, Are Co-counsel. All Have Substantial Experience

12. Robinson, 22, Is Charged With Aggravated Murder And Six

29, 2025. Utah County Officials Say The Increased Attention And