Should You Always Go To Hr Before Calling A Lawyer

Bonisiwe Shabane

-Oct 29, 2025, 5:23 PM

should you always go to hr before calling a lawyer

The people in the human resources department of any company can wear many hats. They’re the people who are often responsible for recruitment, payroll, benefits administration, employee training, and other administrative duties. Importantly, they can also serve as the intermediary party between employees and managers when conflict arises. The ideal work environment is one where everyone is treated with dignity, tempers don’t flare, and the people with power don’t abuse it. Of course, not every work environment is ideal according to these terms. Every day, employees across the country find themselves facing a situation where they’re being unlawfully mistreated at work – should they always go to HR for help?

For answers to your questions and for legal guidance, reach out to Rod Smith Law PLLC for your free consultation! Before we tackle the main question at hand, employees should be aware that there are times when they shouldn’t go to HR. In these cases, however, it would be unlikely that even a lawyer would take your case. A little initiative and self-awareness can save you trouble and heartache at work, after all. You may not want to file a complaint with HR if: Understanding when to seek help from Human Resources (HR) versus when to hire a lawyer is crucial in certain situations.

At Olivier & Schreiber PC, we pride ourselves on assisting our clients to make informed decisions. In this blog, we will discuss the importance of knowing when to go to HR versus hiring a lawyer and how we can help in both scenarios. HR departments serve as the intermediary between employees and managers when conflicts arise. They are tasked with maintaining a healthy work environment and protecting employees’ rights. Filing a formal complaint with HR can indeed fortify a potential lawsuit against your employer, should it come to that. Remember that HR primarily exists to shield the company’s best interests.

Their capacity or willingness to handle serious employment law-related complaints may not always be in line with your expectations. Furthermore, a valid concern for many employees is the risk of retaliation or even termination for reporting unlawful behavior. This is why seeking outside legal counsel may be necessary. In situations involving wrongful termination, discrimination, and harassment, the role of a lawyer becomes pivotal. Lawyers bring legal experience and guidance throughout the process. They can assess the validity of a complaint and advise on the best course of action.

Moreover, if you experience retaliation or termination for reporting unlawful behavior, this can be further grounds for legal action, which a lawyer can guide you through. Every situation is unique and calls for a tailored approach. If you believe your rights have been violated by a business or employer, or if you have lost money due to a company’s wrongful conduct, seeking professional advice is paramount. Facing workplace troubles can feel completely overwhelming, especially when HR isn't as supportive as you'd hoped. You might find yourself thinking, "Should I let HR know I'm hiring an attorney,” or keep it quiet? Making the wrong choice here could add even more stress to an already tense situation.

At Horn Wright, LLP, we understand the anxiety workplace disputes bring. Our experienced employment attorneys know precisely how to handle HR departments, so your rights stay protected. We'll guide you through whether telling HR about your lawyer makes sense, helping you avoid moves that could unintentionally weaken your position. Telling HR you've lawyered up isn't always beneficial. In fact, sometimes it can make things worse. Even if HR claims neutrality, the reality can be quite different.

HR may react negatively once they hear about your legal representation. They might start treating you differently, subtly excluding you, or becoming overly cautious in interactions. Even worse, some employers might retaliate discreetly, putting you in uncomfortable positions or unfairly scrutinizing your performance. Once your employer knows you're preparing legal action, they could also start building their own defenses. This preparation often involves documenting interactions more aggressively or finding reasons (valid or not) to justify their actions against you. When employees encounter issues within their workplace that escalate to conflicts or legal concerns, the Human Resources (HR) department is often the first point of contact.

However, whether turning to HR will effectively address and resolve these issues depends on various factors. At the Law Offices of Jeannette A. Vaccaro PC PC, we’re committed to helping employees understand the implications of informing HR about having legal representation. Call our attorney to discuss the specific factors involved in your case. The HR department handles administrative functions within a company, which can include tasks related to recruitment, addressing employee grievances and more. Ideally, HR acts as a neutral intermediary capable of resolving conflicts impartially.

Yet, this is not always the reality since there are instances when HR is primarily focused on safeguarding the company’s interests. This possible bias towards protecting the company can sometimes result in a lack of genuine concern for the employee’s rights, especially when legal issues are involved. Approaching HR with a grievance can initiate formal documentation of your issue, potentially compelling the company to address it to avoid legal complications. In instances where the company takes corrective action following a complaint to HR, the issue may be resolved satisfactorily without necessitating further legal steps. Additionally, if the situation escalates to a lawsuit, having a record of the complaint can strengthen your case by demonstrating the company’s awareness and inaction. Some employees may fear heightened scrutiny or even retaliation despite such actions being unlawful.

Employers and HR departments may perceive the involvement of an attorney as a prelude to litigation, potentially leading to a defensive and less cooperative stance. Furthermore, any statements made to HR can be meticulously analyzed and potentially used against you in future legal proceedings. It is crucial to recognize that while HR can be a resource for conflict resolution, its primary allegiance often lies with the employer. This duality necessitates careful consideration and strategic planning when deciding to disclose the involvement of legal counsel in employment disputes. No matter what your situation is, it’s important to remember that seeking legal representation can help you navigate the challenges in front of you. If you’re like a lot of people at work, you’re not entirely sure what HR does—and when you should or shouldn’t seek their help, and whether you can trust them when you do.

Some people think HR is a sort of referee between employees and management (they’re not!) or between employees and other employees (they’re usually not that either). So what is HR all about, and when should you approach them? Human Resources covers a huge range of things: benefits, compensation, personnel policy, legal compliance, investigations, hiring assistance, employee relations (which can be anything from identifying and addressing employee complaints to helping a manager address... In larger organizations, these functions are generally separated within HR; you’ll typically find a group of HR staff who are dedicated to recruiting and hiring, another group dedicated to compensation analysis (like benchmarking salaries... Employees often don’t see a lot of what HR does. HR might be most visible to you when you’re first hired since they’ll generally be involved in your hiring and onboarding… but there’s a lot going on behind the scenes.

You often hear people say, “HR works for the company, not the employees.” That’s 100 percent true! But that doesn’t mean that HR is inherently untrustworthy or that you should expect them to be adversarial if you go to them with a problem. It just means that HR’s function is to serve the needs of the company. In many cases, serving the needs of the company also means serving the needs of employees—for example, with things like ensuring the company is offering competitive salaries, addressing bad management, and working to raise... But other times, what’s best for the employer won’t be what’s best for employees. When that happens, the employer’s interests are the ones that will govern because that’s who HR works for.

Good HR people do care about what’s fair and right… but keep in mind that their job is to assess issues through the lens of what makes sense for the company. Navigating the complexities of workplace disputes can be a daunting task, especially when contemplating legal action against your employer. The decision to tell HR that you are getting a lawyer is loaded with potential benefits and risks, making it crucial to weigh your options carefully. With increasing awareness of legal rights and protections, employees must consider both immediate and long-term implications of involving HR in such matters. Understanding HR's role in workplace issues is essential to making an informed decision. HR departments are tasked with balancing their responsibilities towards employee concerns while protecting company interests.

It's vital to recognize how your notification might influence the dynamics of your situation, potentially impacting the resolution process positively or negatively. In this article, we'll explore the intricacies of informing HR about involving a lawyer, examining the benefits, risks, and alternatives. Delve into expert insights on preparing for discussions with HR, crafting your narrative, and optimizing your decision-making strategy. Whether seeking internal resolution or contemplating external intervention, this guide provides a comprehensive overview to enhance your understanding and ensure you make a well-informed choice. Deciding whether to inform your HR department that you are getting a lawyer involves careful consideration. Employees often feel a pressing need to protect their rights, especially when confronting workplace issues like sexual harassment or racial discrimination.

However, it's important to understand that HR's primary responsibility usually leans toward protecting the employer, not the employee. Therefore, revealing your intention to hire legal counsel can significantly alter the dynamics of any HR discussions. Consulting an employment law attorney before making this decision can help you understand your options, potential outcomes, and your employer's possible reactions. Knowing the legal landscape and effectively planning can make all the difference in safeguarding your interests. When faced with workplace issues, making an informed decision about consulting or disclosing involvement with a lawyer is crucial. A lawyer specializing in employment law can offer valuable insights into the legal aspects of your situation.

With their help, you can develop a strategy that anticipates potential HR responses and protects your rights. This preparation can lead to more favorable resolutions to disputes, from unfair dismissals to workplace harassment cases. Before heading into discussions with HR, ensure you gather all relevant documents and fully understand the purpose of the meeting. Remember, being cautious about what you share with HR is important, as information disclosed may be used in legal contexts later. The individuals in the human resources department of any company can don many hats. They’re the people that are typically responsible for employment, payroll, benefits administration, employee training, and other administrative responsibilities.

Importantly, they can also serve as the intermediary party between workers and managers when conflict emerges. The ideal work environment is one where everybody is treated with dignity, tempers don’t flare, and the people with power don’t abuse it. Of course, not every work environment is perfect according to these terms. On a daily basis, employees across the country find themselves facing a situation where they’re being unlawfully mistreated at the workplace– should they always go to HR for assistance? Before we tackle the main question at hand, employees should be aware that there are times when they should not go to human resources. In these cases, however, it would be unlikely that even a lawyer would take your case.

Should You Always Go To Hr Before Calling A Lawyer

People Also Search

The People In The Human Resources Department Of Any Company

For Answers To Your Questions And For Legal Guidance, Reach

At Olivier & Schreiber PC, We Pride Ourselves On Assisting

Their Capacity Or Willingness To Handle Serious Employment Law-related Complaints

Moreover, If You Experience Retaliation Or Termination For Reporting Unlawful