University of Kwazulu-Natal

I Tested Chatgpt Vs Gemini Vs Claude To See Which Chatbot Is The

Bonisiwe Shabane
-
i tested chatgpt vs gemini vs claude to see which chatbot is the

One of these is constantly flattering users When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works. Whether you’re asking ChatGPT for shopping advice or debating philosophy with Claude, there’s one thing most AI chatbots have in common: they’re way too eager to agree with you. New research from Nature says top models are increasingly sycophantic, meaning, they tell users what they want to hear, even when they’re wrong.Just the other day, I uploaded a novel I’m writing into ChatGPT... The response was that it was “New York Times Best Seller-Worthy!” But not once did it tell me I left out Chapter 2.

So I decided to run my own experiment. I put three top chatbots — ChatGPT-5.1, Claude Haiku 4.5, and Gemini 3 — through a series of prompts designed to measure how often they flatter, hedge or simply mirror my opinions. From harmless “you’re right!” moments to responses that bent facts just to stay agreeable, one of these models took people-pleasing to another level. Here’s what happened when I tested today’s most popular AI chatbots to see which one is the biggest sycophant. Your early-adopter friend swears by ChatGPT for meal planning. Your boss thinks Microsoft Copilot will “10x productivity.” Your social media feed thinks Meta AI is a slop machine.

They’re mostly going off vibes. I can tell you which AI tools are worth using — and which to avoid — because I’ve been running a chatbot fight club. When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. I’ve written dozens of features about AI assistants. I’ve compared their features, broken down the latest updates and stress-tested prompts to determine the best ones. But to truly determine which one works best for me and my productivity, I had to use them exclusively one at a time without the temptation of jumping to another.If you’ve been keeping up,...

But not this time. That was off limits for this particular test.For one week, I ran a full-scale experiment. I rotated through ChatGPT (GPT-4o), Claude 4 Sonnet, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Perplexity and DeepSeek as my daily assistant. The only rule was I had to use each one exclusively for a full 24 hours, no switching mid-day. To ensure that I wouldn’t cheat, I reluctantly logged out of every chatbot that I wasn’t allowed to use. From researching why my dishwasher kept tripping and tips to help avoid toddler tantrums to planning meals and helping with my workflow, I put all of the assistants to the test to keep up...

And at the end of the week, only one of them felt like it could stay. Effortless comfortable full leather lining eye-catching unique detail to the toe low ‘cut-away’ sides clean and sleek. Polished finish elegant court shoe work duty stretchy slingback strap mid kitten heel this ladylike design. A clear, practical look at which model writes, researches, and analyzes best — and which you can cancel this year. Claude is best for persuasive, publication-ready writing and the deepest data analysis. ChatGPT is a dependable all-rounder with clear explanations.

Gemini pulls the widest recent sources and niche references but often needs human editing to add warmth or strategy. Most people pay for two or three AI subscriptions. That adds up. You need to know which one earns its keep. I ran 11 hard tests across writing, research, and data work. Scores were based on quality, accuracy, and real usability.

No fluff. Here's the short version: Claude shines for persuasive writing and deep analysis. ChatGPT is the reliable all-rounder. Gemini is fast and broad, but often generic. Those differences matter depending on how you work. If you publish polished copy with little editing, Claude saves time.

If you need clear business analysis and safe factual answers, ChatGPT is steady. If you want access to the widest recent sources, Gemini pulls extra context — sometimes at the cost of voice. A comparison of how ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude compare in accuracy, depth, and real-world performance across SEO, coding, research, and everyday tasks. Chatbots have changed many professionals’ workflows and processes. Accountants, lawyers, SEO experts, writers, agencies, developers, and even teachers are still discussing the changes taking place in their field thanks to tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude. If you want to search for information, need help fixing bugs in your CSS, want to create something as simple as a robots.txt file, or need shopping recommendations, chatbots may be able to help.

They’re also wonderful for topic ideation, allowing you to draft more interesting emails, newsletters, blog posts, and more. But which chatbot should you use and learn to master? Which platform provides accurate, concise information? ⚡ We tested ChatGPT-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, and Claude 4 head-to-head. See which AI wins for coding, writing, and real-world tasks. Shocking results inside!

> 🔥 Plot Twist Alert: The results aren't what you'd expect! One underdog AI dominated categories we thought were locked up. > 💡 Want to try these tools? Check out our complete AI tools directory with exclusive deals and detailed reviews of 21+ AI assistants! The AI wars have never been fiercer. With ChatGPT-5's launch claiming "Ph.D.-level expertise," Google's Gemini 2.5 Pro flexing its multimodal muscles, and Claude 4 Sonnet quietly dominating accuracy tests, we had to find out which AI truly reigns supreme.

We put these titans through 15 rigorous tests across coding, writing, math, creativity, and real-world scenarios. The results will surprise you. Learn how to build a complete Django discussion forum with anonymous posting, user interactions, and... These AI tools offer a range of functionalities to enhance the creative process for vloggers.... Discover complete iPhone 16 specifications for all models. Compare features, camera specs, performance, and pricing...

Compare ChatGPT vs. Gemini vs. Claude in 2025 with comprehensive benchmarks on reasoning, creativity, accuracy, and real-world applications. Find the perfect AI assistant for your needs. The landscape of AI assistants has evolved dramatically over the past year, with OpenAI's ChatGPT, Google's Gemini, and Anthropic's Claude all vying for market dominance. Which one truly delivers the best experience for different use cases?

This comprehensive analysis breaks down everything you need to know to choose the right AI assistant in 2025.

People Also Search

One Of These Is Constantly Flattering Users When You Purchase

One of these is constantly flattering users When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works. Whether you’re asking ChatGPT for shopping advice or debating philosophy with Claude, there’s one thing most AI chatbots have in common: they’re way too eager to agree with you. New research from Nature says top models are increasingly sycophantic, mean...

So I Decided To Run My Own Experiment. I Put

So I decided to run my own experiment. I put three top chatbots — ChatGPT-5.1, Claude Haiku 4.5, and Gemini 3 — through a series of prompts designed to measure how often they flatter, hedge or simply mirror my opinions. From harmless “you’re right!” moments to responses that bent facts just to stay agreeable, one of these models took people-pleasing to another level. Here’s what happened when I te...

They’re Mostly Going Off Vibes. I Can Tell You Which

They’re mostly going off vibes. I can tell you which AI tools are worth using — and which to avoid — because I’ve been running a chatbot fight club. When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. I’ve written dozens of features about AI assistants. I’ve compared their features, broken down the latest updates and stress-tested prompts to deter...

But Not This Time. That Was Off Limits For This

But not this time. That was off limits for this particular test.For one week, I ran a full-scale experiment. I rotated through ChatGPT (GPT-4o), Claude 4 Sonnet, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Perplexity and DeepSeek as my daily assistant. The only rule was I had to use each one exclusively for a full 24 hours, no switching mid-day. To ensure that I wouldn’t cheat, I reluctantly logged out of every chatbot that ...

And At The End Of The Week, Only One Of

And at the end of the week, only one of them felt like it could stay. Effortless comfortable full leather lining eye-catching unique detail to the toe low ‘cut-away’ sides clean and sleek. Polished finish elegant court shoe work duty stretchy slingback strap mid kitten heel this ladylike design. A clear, practical look at which model writes, researches, and analyzes best — and which you can cancel...