Generating Fact Checking Explanations Arxiv Org
arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website. Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them. Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs. arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website.
Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them. Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs. Most existing work on automated fact checking is concerned with predicting the veracity of claims based on metadata, social network spread, language used in claims, and, more recently, evidence supporting or denying claims. A crucial piece of the puzzle that is still missing is to understand how to automate the most elaborate part of the process – generating justifications for verdicts on claims.
This paper provides the first study of how these explanations can be generated automatically based on available claim context, and how this task can be modeled jointly with veracity prediction. Our results indicate that optimising both objectives at the same time, rather than training them separately, improves the performance of a fact checking system. The results of a manual evaluation further suggest that the informativeness, coverage and overall quality of the generated explanations are also improved in the multi-task model. When a potentially viral news item is rapidly or indiscriminately published by a news outlet, the responsibility of verifying the truthfulness of the item is often passed on to the audience. To alleviate this problem, independent teams of professional fact checkers manually verify the veracity and credibility of common or particularly check-worthy statements circulating the web. However, these teams have limited resources to perform manual fact checks, thus creating a need for automating the fact checking process.
The current research landscape in automated fact checking is comprised of systems that estimate the veracity of claims based on available metadata and evidence pages. Datasets like LIAR Wang (2017) and the multi-domain dataset MultiFC Augenstein et al. (2019) provide real-world benchmarks for evaluation. There are also artificial datasets of a larger scale, e.g., the FEVER Thorne et al. (2018) dataset based on Wikipedia articles. As evident from the effectiveness of state-of-the-art methods for both real-world – 0.492 macro F1 score Augenstein et al.
(2019), and artificial data – 68.46 FEVER score (label accuracy conditioned on evidence provided for ‘supported’ and ‘refuted’ claims) Stammbach and Neumann (2019), the task of automating fact checking remains a significant and poignant... A prevalent component of existing fact checking systems is a stance detection or textual entailment model that predicts whether a piece of evidence contradicts or supports a claim Ma et al. (2018); Mohtarami et al. (2018); Xu et al. (2018). Existing research, however, rarely attempts to directly optimise the selection of relevant evidence, i.e., the self-sufficient explanation for predicting the veracity label Thorne et al.
(2018); Stammbach and Neumann (2019). On the other hand, Alhindi et al. (2018) have reported a significant performance improvement of over 10% macro F1 score when the system is provided with a short human explanation of the veracity label. Still, there are no attempts at automatically producing explanations, and automating the most elaborate part of the process - producing the justification for the veracity prediction - is an understudied problem. In the field of NLP as a whole, both explainability and interpretability methods have gained importance recently, because most state-of-the-art models are large, neural black-box models. Interpretability, on one hand, provides an overview of the inner workings of a trained model such that a user could, in principle, follow the same reasoning to come up with predictions for new instances.
However, with the increasing number of neural units in published state-of-the-art models, it becomes infeasible for users to track all decisions being made by the models. Explainability, on the other hand, deals with providing local explanations about single data points that suggest the most salient areas from the input or are generated textual explanations for a particular prediction. arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website. Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them. Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community?
Learn more about arXivLabs. Automated fact-checking systems often struggle with trustworthiness, as their generated explanations can include hallucinations. In this work, we explore evidence attribution for fact-checking explanation generation. We introduce a novel evaluation protocol, citation masking and recovery, to assess attribution quality in generated explanations. We implement our protocol using both human annotators and automatic annotators, and find that LLM annotation correlates with human annotation, suggesting that attribution assessment can be automated. Finally, our experiments reveal that: (1) the best-performing LLMs still generate explanations with inaccurate attributions; and (2) human-curated evidence is essential for generating better explanations.
Code and data are available here: https://github.com/ruixing76/Transparent-FCExp. Evaluating Evidence Attribution in Generated Fact Checking Explanations Rui Xing1 Timothy Baldwin1,2 Jey Han Lau1 1The University of Melbourne 2MBZUAI ruixing@student.unimelb.edu.au, tb@ldwin.net, jeyhan.lau@gmail.com The dissemination of online misinformation poses a significant threat to society, with consequences ranging from seeding skepticism and discrediting science, to endangering public health and safety. To verify online claims at scale, automated fact-checking systems have been proposed to classify claims based on their truthfulness (Guo et al., 2022). However, debunking by simply calling a claim “false” can lead to a backfire effect, whereby the belief in a false claim is further reinforced rather than hindered (Lewandowsky et al., 2012).
As such, there’s growing research on generating textual explanations to justify the outcomes of fact-checking systems using large language models (LLMs) in various contexts (Eldifrawi et al., 2024; Wiegreffe et al., 2022). For automated fact-checking, the typical input is a claim and a list of retrieved evidence passages, from which a subset of evidence passages is selected and fed to the LLM for explanation generation. Table 1 presents a typical example of the fact-checking task with a generated explanation, and Figure 1 illustrates the process of generating these explanations. Pepa Atanasova, Jakob Grue Simonsen, Christina Lioma, Isabelle Augenstein [Generating Fact Checking Explanations](https://aclanthology.org/2020.acl-main.656/) (Atanasova et al., ACL 2020) ACL materials are Copyright © 1963–2025 ACL; other materials are copyrighted by their respective copyright holders.
Materials prior to 2016 here are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 International License. Permission is granted to make copies for the purposes of teaching and research. Materials published in or after 2016 are licensed on a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The ACL Anthology is managed and built by the ACL Anthology team of volunteers. Site last built on 27 November 2025 at 10:42 UTC with commit 542848d. arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website.
Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them. Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs. �� ���C Q���,��9U�/M�v �b�D�*˯��ؔ&�Oz��VsM��{�ɻUٟۉ�,˗�ݵh��!��M�����xA9��.�\��ۉ��:�d_s��X*�O�h�n���o�H���L7�{∈�4�y�JkDos���� ��%�����"��&�����������I�l�_�eD)���3%���ɐI����6`��\�@��RQ�A���/oc5��f�=�����&����L����p\�v��**����L ���'[1���0Ai�� ��E�H�����somS�����1��zi�rf*����=�l�Q�%S �|G#IUF��\L���� ^�uO>�����m�4I���w�����n)'���!V�:���q*�g�Y�ix�,�7��@ ������D,��`Ϊ�2�b� �H�{?����v:�&�Һ>LG�vn�a>O� �x��7����w��O���0���-nk G�v4,�p@�~� ;�5M��SS����Wɽʌ�{N��E�D`��>�Ix �����vͿV����}u..q��O�<�iBb��9�{���my� ��V�3W���{hU���"p�1`� *����� θ1�W�%*��܁^�0�K �,�~�=��{��+�%T �&S���An�ݬ@xq���������'�)���\!�T@n,[�Tt��耰� endstream endobj 608 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Length1 903 /Length2 1352 /Length3 0... ��V�ߞ���殽�Je[ލؾ�sHFE� C�Ѩ������)�x���a���~����êl�6itL�3�wѩ� 8c �;!�Z�dm��R^�u����@[��v�]W����NMrߘ~��n֝e��ȣ�[�(9����kӚܓ��r4�����Q���Wn�g�o��-�0�1�5�jTH�ׄ��c�O���(� X_t#�#.z�H�Z�^'�6h�e.��?$*��j_�����?-��-��������Q�[��J�i=�%�@q9����i=Q+4����,Y[���s!�4�sw�Zd�`�:&��.���e��&ck9W��Ղ��0����V�D�O��|���y�{e£�7쌮���ә�ͷ�����un]�zj�+��&�@���qV�m�'������./��R���ܣ�X������-�U��0# endstream endobj 610 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Length1 1269 /Length2 1131 /Length3 0 /Length 1841 >> stream xڝS Tg.��lPWp?B,P�L�<�B@A@��!�$�L �P[�Py ,�����I�eY��\`EKy�" ��nŊ;��J�=g��9sf��}�~�~��Y B��"<��Ag1 w��A��!|��n�"�D���PB��@�mG� (����Q"0A�|a�dD "�(�X.�,�;� ���%W�>*� �Ja���|pE��H�7...
�[��af�c�(�%����:G�Z7I��-�.�͔>$��� BX��C�n��N���ծ?�:䷓�B�F��� }���X@l>�K=�Z)�߯:#'#t( �t5�Ϸd�j� 5���P�ssK��RMPѬ| �5zׄHl%�����<��� m���96���Y$�։���l�-T�/VJ´y�0�#� ���c������XGKL���}~�]y�=��X#��S��ܳ��?��\*����.��H>�z�-b{Jfs��U�&ݰ {l߄-�U����&[�v�iS���M��m׃��E�$Ṟ3��"h;�&�/~<���F@����B�uu���iLֈW�ύČ�6��[N������7�xRL��XeYTtpK،:,O �xӕ��R�����Y_�Kpw2f#���% %P�x 4���s�}�_�y83}F��< ����K����r��C�ɝ���x�W�>rz��M��.�&!tX��[��Nڌ+A���e��q@�@m-5������=� �(湸�a�T��Ad���J�M��p�M30I#��Dzk��64�[�J(���K�>Z[2��k��� L�&/P���|�Ǘʟ�`gwu� Ƀ���MQ�]�),�T!� �p92��{��������B[�����uZ���u ���#��C�.��o��Q���:,8��N���A?�C��`>�{���̦&�=Ek����=5D�j��)9J �s���+�d'�#x~��> ��͑�˦H*��5x�̫�Z,o�jۤ919��n���9��=ǝi�~\pW�/���V��=�Vt J�&�nR���z9����e�����ND��`�X��O>���>�0�sޔ�_9����E�w��x�����4!�^|�v�A^^,��;����y���~���%� �����;��9=Ӄ�m��ū��Nf�":��*0n������X�j/LJ��o�&��?����̫=a��[VS�.����J��~<���`���i>,�E�/��Cͦ�Q��e�) ��#��S:��]�%��B�ʽ�N%�>f!խ�3ɋ��1����;j �\ gP�{��p ��E� �FU \�S�=ig�a�{ iRg蛡z�����xX7�j��< ݊X��+�։�NP�,CX����e<�����p�bN���[����n������r%5c]��e�V�ӛ��]��.���2��EW4�ܐ��0H�1�1ǿ��3�4%Pv�r�E�'��l�YՉ�bW�8���ԟ@DŏE�U1t�x���LɊ�ȝ�8;#� )9�w��w�� �zR|S>�52����C��C2V��؟�*�Z/��Z��E�(�����_q���i����.���Ƿ��x�a�l���/jN;B�D8DhU����N�p?]Y8��e��}�BEB)�M���lKNQ5g0�-��5��J: [�0������%p�z��$vא�~� to$��ң�W��tr�Z��N... E5�{�=�S�e���╴�eK=�&�� �a���0 �_�H�n����S��'߀+�T�2R�V�9w�o�ܞlVd�Ά���\S�37K��sV��2�JI�_�y/w�YkQ������m���� ��]!Q%GJR��i���G{ Q� 3i�<*0�vã+Qi�� �����N��*^�g{�{�w\L����V[�����������t��4�vSX](/e ;x�|X��İ4z�8 ���~�*�wA.� ����]����Dq�TU��O�O���(�n��TVKޢb� G�@�T>�y6.�5�~!�n��#��&��c��z���DL>���rz�}^I�bOiC�E��|+h���e� 5C�ZB�7Eݮ ���)'4�m���h�k�����C&�-O��I�.��SF��y��3�"��V��DA̎+�ז������~~2��j�{9��/��.�5����gX�o`�L�kH\��q�����j ��$�ڌ�2'�C�e¼�?PR"餿��o�����͡ד#F���!0kJoNo�RF�L����S5>��$�|HV�3������T�d$��c�O��g q�>GEg�}���xѽIS��A� n[��%}ə\Obر:�*���L��V��5� ����I�x �Bq �� ��;�����|#Q�tE+�YB4�J��H99�q�E,�{}]����x^�� � ڔ�����������-�}f��rC�)��b-]��n����ok�v� gL��H %/�&�9�C��/�Q��3|�b/&����7`*w+��Б|�+S��X'�� �v$����/$�n�_(�U��#Nl�"Q�V=sф�P�&�U)�Yv����y�g���9��0�!�~L�\o8�t��`����-�_n��7��z4���!z�1L��WIЂys�p���5��1��hx���n�ڀ'fw���3"��܈ b��$��W1��æ�̄���Us�\yn4s��]��k=rZ��v��8��+Y�,Ą���o�S"5 �N���PE�U(�aÂ��ێ#� � �V�����ھ�)�ֆ�?k^ -���ƙGt D���^���l]RJ����?K���(F�� ��>��`h'7֣׀������(�dؠF��-c�>�6��[T� y����w�������&�l�wv^�8NxF�[�}0ԋ� �d1͔gR�z��5��... � 8/�Y�HmX{Ȋ��,�N53���У�=�0_6��1�'k�#<>_V���6�s�^�0 ���]���~Cd"��F8��z���YVK��1O����۱7pU�{�"�yՓ�RC�4�5S�*���@�� �D.qaK�tn�+}�c��pw×�����6��ת�3!��b��;@C6�|��e gI7���.�hO�Bƅ���� ���G�9��@K�m�v�m۶m۶m۶m�6�L2����ޕJjU)��h&�գF��g���C�w�L6�yÖ���b�U�C����Q����A}m��=�8c�)�����k0�ص,�~̻کj��N1)��fR�bh��W-y" ��;yp~�M�|��l�54�G�O�-�DV�o�n�N�r�-�#5LbNBzy��7d�����5��$nT�Qy���6x��!6�`�bMY(�V���A��C�&��m0����hȅ�ּ�Di�4s�L�g@�s�3�`��i�՜/+o���/F G�����~��65_��� W�)�����~� ���N�kN�g���-�D ��%8��z����!Jq@���sX~����_t͗cǟ�/;|�q d� ��89V�a"�u ���J}�q��m"gXyع�M�1��`�|�OC��v~�[SU��5��K�ZF�cc��m��B=p�'�N).�7���ʍ^���Ч1��i ����͡$�s������ �����۾��kN�%?t��䅻P�u]*+����y�����rB' �.�O����͜�����pmTP��q��>w�E��0�:�������pvz����T����Z��Hׅ|��|���N����p��itY���m�R�hڄx@�8bv5�˹��K/�a` �v"�F�1�p�l����bd^{�B�\��N�Q��!����U:���%��ۨ����I\.2�eOl��(t:�GD� yK�Vv\�s�\ �/���j�rL�b�� ߋ�u;歠�GV��B�o� o��o���qR�����˘5�Q���ʝ��>N��C��X )���V��ǃ���f%p��%G��{h���no@L�(m�..vq��.#��3�@�z�wh"E5� �F�AW���-&���U�?�?Y��h*��? Z���Y�b� ?���xCJ����;[��Db7�j����Y���﨏.[�u��T�C9��MlH�ŪD]�����4N��� w��m��G�aκ�Y*;tc�!$�?��k�<U�g]�uQN6�(ip�?s��%S�v�k�o+"�/T�S ��L9b��S�A��v�}�d������L)T˳�mn�w��Lld���t��iL]J�����\�)��|��c���}� {b��M�{g�߇���>ʫÑ&���임��[�=W�J$�WC�����9�� ?�O&��}�nw?���vw��#p� �:��zvYR:�4o�mr�G��T.h�1t�RY�C�"��_��ɭ�J� �5��=�#Q"�3�gN�HN�G�p! �l�?�)��-�'� fڿ��%njjB���ȹ�r�f�:�4�\W����J'ЄNY�t��G��Iӂ�'Ƒd#C{U�6�:��"���z�F�7�i�Lf�{H# S��>�T2ES�r�. T���h����|;g��Á��(Xķki-�A.�j�-m5bf��GWz�@��Et��!W��ә]L �S)&�:��M'�@�2�JJ��v~��W`��'�P::��T�1���9=] O�̺��7��X��P��T2�;N��C�u5��{���>�����_t�V������ԝ�����]��W�8 ��n��� ��\m����/J<Y¦�|��1)?����[9~(��ʹ�v���a�N�|]� ��N7z� ��t�K�y�J�:��zx����M}��c�g�>-��u �_���t��r�5���eG3�B����j���fA�t�/�Y���a��,BJ1ks3N��2�LZ��4d����G>[i����I.�.dI(j�Ɠ�88XɌ��H:$OW�[�c{pR/���fj�f�]j���7��mbK7p�e� ؊<��ӓ�q�e"�F�HKz�O���?'*�:�8�mU��Y���+g���ï�[M�L`}�Y�oA���l��W:���wO�E������r�m�H(#a$wl �X4���4z7��l��$���Բ��/7�>W�\��۽.��v7��jǜuy�?��`���F K��g��^sn�UL_��5[L�v+ߝ5L�"�0I�pㅋ���4�n&n��y�'���t'E�h�vU�F���\V#�g6l��P_��M�0/��>`���xO��Z���s�+ -�q4k!1F�n�0� �O1:�� �8�����yh�GgҮCk�/N��?Y��"�Ȕւ\�P���a�8V����5}#m�C~�ٷ`�I:#�� }N`�B�Q����� ���Ö�%�%�6��H��p�xF��8f���2��|��Ј����M����#$ng֊�.����9'�?�K'5�Y������DU{>Cm�Wc�Rna콜�Z�Pi"ξp?�Ʉ���@�h���ܱ�/:G��}���U�v �7���9�RvZ�<�y+�C�1�2̰c+ \����U@L>c��O���4d��%����ɸr����Q6L�����K>q��r � c�Bt��`<øe��V�u��h�٦��gF��SAf$By7s�'N��|�Y6��2�:J�~��Fw���̔�"�N�����E 6L�E�7�1��������DU�>��P��b�87ve�a��ܛ ��U�}qtnߓ��{��@�(��L8}�FwoɈ��gs!0Qc���<šKQ���:�`t�����,�Xױ�!G�בeK�Pg��� ����,�?@�@#��q�c7�b�̋t#Fz��� �� �e�%�t�)cnx[�<�'#�Z� �k���7�� �wЉ�k��_��2|Ra�Ѕ�֭���F�S�����b� ֕��|1ro�Rb�ȡK�Y7d�6�q�|2�X�����t�/�%~˼�}�17�p��s�����mIJ7�����m��P�z`�HU9??r���ih�(E^w��X0<�.N;�U�do��#go���7?��sx����]�^e��\�H}�^���{�8�͝;�+�^��qȳ��6� �'z'����y�_)?�m9�]cCQ;#���>�� G۬w��Yk����߫3g��]�a���o�4��V0���SqȀ�XUC����U8����-L�/FҚ��7��^;���h�������6��Ӄ� �^ �RT�g̓d� m�k� ���������N�t�...
�jCZW�/�R��:7��¤rc6Ct�,�� ơ�������]s�(5�y��S%�w c�?N ���>P-�cTl�����e�U���9!�$���R��&K�`L%�����a���6���nj�Y�A0ǮH��|��~|졗!#V�l˪�[���7����)]q>���G�Y澶5�'q���O.��H���<�����y3��r��2iۦb����Z �2g�B��eW�_q}��5�Y��-l�s �X��t����D�Jf��7�ǰm� ڔUm�¿Ím6��� �Åp�����c'd]Laμ�'e�$�}����w�M���s�`���u���L }����r����'��o�6����j�@���#�vc�T�!�N�8Qqf��='A���h1�hJ�o"e��D��v���8�y��gx�"bO=i�s8ngk�s����\��t$�TG���IXwl���=�F��F�� �G(y�c>��U���G,��(ُ�~�Ot����� �/���ͫ��#�5U�}�Lɷ��P�N�3�����X�'n��A�BP&���`�J����BR�SU�7M<�)�O���`����{Ca{�pA��?xƭ:\;�^j�X�{E'�J0�?�=�P��KO�3�pe25�̎&�D>I�덳PWM��ɥz:� �{%�Ӻ~�%�e��혦��ri���i�f� �Ն�)|<.�|Y���`��HE�d�פx[�d䃩�5^14$��. ���D�]�����}D0� Ѕ�Vz�m������f�����"J�B�- ��1.t�7Y�Eb�n��\a@a�U��BZௐ�?Qlm�P�ȶ�Uᇎ#[T�2 ]�po*��������J3�-�I�%(���{�=��h �Q�%s�=XX�Q�No�ȷ�, ���T�z~��"�[]Td�.��y �����H�����2B�=��(��-�`�p�cf� ����_�eIl}h�G�i 6*����C���v!-MC��'��Q��j��!�8B6�Ŷ 5�3v;Q�`�����T{��( �ݦٴS��xg���p��[�J� IG��ܬ���>�"2e��f9d%�b�wJf|�{����ʪ�'��G���:�VK"/G��K�+��D�')i�D$��p]{�&(�{�J]�^�&;8� ,��DL�/�O����֩�'�ϛ���I��X�'�o�L�u~�s�;0��c ��$&$>�LC�0^�~g�KمDN�M�ȥ��8�$��B�r,��&|�ُqF��g;�Tv���Jc8B\u5��q�������[JR���R3А�U����Vi��ll��$$�I��JqJ�p��*��`�eY4�]lW4�X^E�I��sr��3} �ȑ�B�@��2��y����̂�.;W*aI#�~k�b�Ԫ���p1�O�Ik�Oe>t�d��[z�ϸ�Ȗ�(� �+,�{��y���Nx�ozr�Wt���o�1V�ȇ�ZY ��n#�~Sw1���5=���K'5駽����M��Gd@���3mN9���F�Y+�2��c�9�nX3�<��*����n2��L<83�)Prp�[;���H1��&� F����DT�?�� 4��xi�أ;���\�? G �� ����m�D���Ɣ��D��v�F[@�T��J�k�3Ĵ%Ʉ�`� ͉��=�{��*����7����RR�kBO�9"�_�#� 5��$������ e����i�'�@�U���U�Z����8K D�M�|ˎ���m�M��ֲq��k����WHΒ5� �֜�K{oE���Wa,@���Ҿ猿�����Jq�yha\�C��Nl�k}�ȴ��G� P%���!,��^� ��E�o�,�`�ZI,|>v(�e��N�y����ٶ���yxL�����l��Ҷ�Wg�? 6�ﰭ�2,�M��f/KCc$�����j�(7�PO��=�d��/VGOA��°D��g��5lf%��Ґw�T�(��%h���W�����c@is���s#�����l�� f�x���� ��j�Uv)\��y�e$Wϕ_�J���c� @{ �ð�fgw �V��W%�m�3(&�����4�"�e��ow��(�C����*H�Ꙫۣ�� �o���,��� H<����}�i(���v xQ�4O�˕`�N�ԗ��G�5�#�g���vͻ��� XZ�%%��MyX��=�<�v��ST�6�[�O��M�����-/�Ts� ��� �%<�˕ЛJ�|�����s3U��an���H3@Ӫ�f(cC�0�ߏ�4��EV����yp��ۅ霙->��;���T���M{f+���m�#OnKW���[[�QAx=+ՙ �ڋ�2�%�S���IT� ;8ʽ��Ĕ����79�Έ��Qŝ}`0�ω`k?���'Y��,�v�&5) #�P�чY��~csȕC 4�y"s����� ?~1����x;tՆ/s:���I!^�v�JA���� �D�<�*��9 �n�%��)�w��Y��j�s���2W�WI&��'-�T��_~�I�tV�� �l��`>��Ԛ�Lv�eD��Ս �'^��i�& H(0�d��f�$($����!EP�`ZZC��Ύ�w8}�#�h�S.��Z��P�gr����i��IMR� �4�'�T�>� ]�*{�����x<��x�}8�f��^ڇT]�?b�#�iB�U���*��.����(ˏ�I��b�����ƛ�+�=�Oգ�.�M��|)�XI���t9kk ?e��J��.����7Z^�N�@d wΠ[|8,өֳ��;��X���K������6��)&*�f:w&~|6� ��7�!�����B/s�-��6��l;o tB�������sV����va�G/љ�nVFYDf�b�/��}��gWÜ��M���F�� �#���9| �R3���eYK� th�%�!��T����/wt%���jЀt2n�G�ª-:=����f.�H�*��w�6�aa�h��2E}��2Aw���<]��XJ���T�#Fs�����?�ȭ����̪��ܻA9Mj��S=ɨ|��h��4O'+�ܒ���n��oK��C0MN��|�7�,�������D��_���{�H�;u�~��y���"��K�">{{X]�{��qj\�����@�+&�^�����<��x�X����>�:��u�>H�Ɠ�[��L�5� /�;v��=<ԏ�� _�/��y4o=���=�Su,'�K-fCMv��S��]�/�66o�H�WS���[ 93��N��#:�q���tF���8��N�՟}�?Z��pAk�'�R���I���=&���oX��;I���I{�H�T��l����Ps�C�q�}�j... �E8�Sy�c�p�!���Ldb�L�Ѿ�+��+ɇ��F<���p�i��-&�Vn���5 �#�����(^�*��bh�{�{��h�n��V��D�dX�����Nۂ����y�����B? x��Kb�Xuz Y��N��2@$����?F��<�, �No~A��y��mw��z�2��� mЛ���а�Vq��t71�8�N�p֣�����X���j#��5��K�i�?�W���F��K6�\Oj�%��3����/|�YV�y3n�w�?Ƕ�t\��P�Q����cn����/�1��%���� 4W���5t�PC��*��s(�g� �\/7�0���X\� G������k{����������d�i�����ݑ�/��ۆ�4:t�u�`h��ٛ�AS���^����K�4�$:孹/'���g,�k�A�@|Ŗ�y�T��4A�KjJWT�)5��uR�}�{�-�n����b?��y��y�*ۡF�h5��u���%q-���_�T�kLU�v�v4��K��^� �;�g�E�-���<�;$��O)�yM�y}^�71�sOnF�S�yȽ�c����m<��������a�p�<��7�U�za�~�jڿ���l~�I$h��7�_Q$ ���Ng�ExĄ��ǡ[�Fk�� �Ȕb��<��H�;���;77�Rt�XџHK�_U��֣������ȍ�k��� ľ�<5��`���R��9T���(����k%��X��I���'z��b��������ҋ�;���`�,�{$Z�V�6n�4�"%o�6�Ͻ�Q.+Q�KZ��:��L�W,4,=�1h�+D:��2����T�%�;W(j��ػY�.?�)+�m�JX���jf��#��w���I��B���P��B���e�R�><�0f�K�n�|���L� �~}9�+� �wkJ�>Y�Lx �>\\<�zy�W��jM�&��o�@���q8 VF�4��w�S]D�Q�L|�~lJ�.�*0�?�ƚ� ���{�^z�(J���^����S �/N�����º����+\��z�V��3��ݫ:�0�Ҹ��R�)<,��t~�1_U8�@�����c��Kn�=��j�~e���D2��[,E�4&��U�Խ�Ma�s��ˀ��U�~h��9(�&� ��`�_��� �s��)�'.��Ҁ�}mlO.��U*�<�:3d�|l|k]���.�<�Q!4a7��.}�����$=����� ���f��a��ħRļC�6:rw�2�9 WXP��0P<�F�R�A�L�T��|����v�R4�"*�ԟ��6�^R��E~�T��`�I���ҹ��=��#�泥(��eYXyX�_+w�5 ;@����өB���e~T�:ӆ_r}���E&Q*�1�>�Vg_�NW7 �WV��*[Uq9�Hx�a?�o,G�ǟ�7��Њ:3Uu�S9��Z���)>�/��SN�;����"�u%��=�H���E����ߊ;"ћG -#s ͉�m�������#�\{�Ej7���ǁ��DOF�K�ފ���%F#����[� |l��� (��%���Q= �)�H� ���b$ B6�b6�R�>B �߷��KY��9^��[1��0�6�Xa��Q d��ޗ<�J|�*�i�MϺ�0����%ő�:W9�l��[�g?&#՛7\��9af�m�e��� ��2<�x*#�K���Y2_�2&� {[10�... 77@|`� �l�X/: �y@+������>�7��0���R���-T���q���C�S�����h�ȓRɎ�D���/��� ���¬�Bz�ݫsw+%�fTt[Z��:�%/��̳l�/_�Q )�j���#�M���z��t\�\�\ܵ[Bn�6��8M}��{ �gkR7Cd@��+ j�]ΈŚ�*I�Z��4"d��S�!�qP.3�[��B�(�{��}�{����GW<7B�����"X � mw�~%���yh�@E��C�SY@#�7;�pJ>���Vo�E�{���� �|�F��-8��՝��h��`v��h��GP�����B\��.I="�> �K���X��P��C�r�u ����@�\�R��L|��I�B搎gW[�X8R��g�3�rܼapM<�Ч v�ǔcD �~���MI� >SK-`#�.����A��$�0nӀ;�l�*要�jv��e���k��B���?�`�S��V S��m��ʛ�F��ٳ��9~PH�<3 ^�\��$I`�O�yM4B��"�ҭ0�S\�p�Z!����d�GwM�W��U�*<��?��"3$��K���BP�ī �OLc�o±���n���~>���2�H{���ʬ ��{�����[�3a��٠�S���u{j����!1�f�s�l��^5���4�[i��_�oGbTu�[L�bS;�Md ��.zw$Һ�_9�Sx���=�U;�?C'�Cr ^L��P��eey�m��SKe�i��Jۨ�G�k�L�w�7�1�`B���I��x�)U� f�-�S?d�� z��JT�R���� b�p>%8�l/����3̨��c[�;��^V�N�D�����`Zl��w���Y�`&K�pK��s�SS��&�*tW�� &�?~�#�5��2o@;�$��$���w� ��({���58T�;�< ���K^���@*oD�8�l&t�bx��#���?����0�Gi\��wϿD�N����X����@?VJx���P���JGb��ё�D��i�|��2E�~�7�x��j�"��x-a�cx��y(k��Ø�[�n��0b~� ��:="�3�*H�Ǜ��<�f�Eع�G� ��z;�#l����2�B���N�,�t����$&�j�C3���z�'��,4� �g9�de����)���r�����*.��L)�{�@�N_W�0M|[#��E�6y�J!4d��f��M7�Ϋ��T4A�^J�G��h=ó�̷��uW������[Yo�vV�J �;�z ���%��۵���6����o��a� R[7]'��d�)ύwC�3gL��� ��ڔWŖ�Y(��x�8Y��\m�Nqc*��u`w�9e�^�uco�`���pv��8�u��v��pw��"q*:�A.��ܺ}������9���|��*��p��7���,9+���cm����Z...
����(�xz�%��j��R�o{��;�/4DQ@�l������ے�eN��8�jz�J�*[�]��9�H�o�v<_��%�a�a`)�{7��n&�)\�yf�z���\��s�h�Ϧ:Vқ�4�CB��I̾��e���}O������pg ����mI �h�����ߐXjؖ6��*��8& �F-�.�����լ)�mu%5*gr���>��G���:�m� .��kRI�nY' �xg思?DG,�fL��mv�Ԑ��|�燒l硷�C.���bg�߭��q�{/.@%y�l�e-���M�r�T1��� �W8���ƈ�]p�؛!z���b���{Pta��@�:�q�߂�~�`@:X����.>`L9�e's�^E���k?��/9ؖٞ�"8�{��w�R���p��@�n��X�w�W����y�7 ibD�C��%�n ���W��_*���]Em6F��3��2���M͚ۢy ��죪1G�2����i����tr���ZN�䝳��K�l\�{��;~oZ�;�1ٝ]ҏ�p���ʰ��`�vW����8���L�Z��t�d F�Cƒ�E�!<�"1�sO���ꗍZ���-ѹW*Z�ɽ��� $P��<> p@��#6�EN�a)��������M�� ���/��@��w j�bZ<���q��q�"�;Sҋ;�m�������Im�Bj'���ufќ�V�x1BJ/M�\1c� ��LJF�I N4Ҋ�#O��~�E�ʍC��n!(ƵDm2�F��.j����GÀ�C��c�i2����>QX?���/w64�m�li&��� M8��i����j8�&��tX�F�cn4��C�X���=�7R ������ꍋ��:��5� h/&�x���A}�v�i ���<����Px� t�VS}2�۠��c����������f/���w+*R�4������!���4Qj��t��)B{�lTd�>I;Yh��zo�.�5"p�k3\ uq�|s�X��� f�����5ZW���C�X���4�FP�i$T�9�G r�JA�4L*�"�i�h:��(.�4��;�L���끚~'�t�K+&o)2�Hu�چ�A/1���J�lBp�3�� �o��w̌K�G���'���D��lt;{w}����p�T7d��HC-FѦ�;�`���?>G?r���m,�PpJ�M=���>ôm p�瑲)���*5�>�N�Tʻpᾈ���;�ſ���*<���/�χ�q�� �Ib������ՠ~[����L��o8x�x�B��aٰ� �0�����輊� &�*�a� ��VC σ�2�I+Х����%��(o��k������2�a�f�>���߶�d�Uq�rH�C�OI'�P�G%\�kfΟ��f����:\' �+ ���&�HJ>!�c:��xQ�0�lۜ... ��o��SS�/r,b�LxHz�K��嶩�j�"FR5���=*�'���e�o�\�RxRB�{W��K�R�69Ŗ�{\v�D��7,F��پ��-(�g��R�c��&Lw���4Uj� �0D��"���p�PA^��T�)���v�2�\�`e�����ak*���z(�8��ӁTgݿ� E �W RU��)�M�:KK��O�����Տ�i�-�^�Sp��Z����g>�^Q��>�[�D#�����[�>�\����z \%�Q@"�9�{�[D��$�����x����vOLr�J�|u}nݰ���]�q��vp���լ��=|ղױDs2�~�Ȉ���lz�y�]���hr1yw`{P,t���� :�+������g${xيd\�y���e�T5)�`7g�ʡ�,�ݛ*V6٬���d��vn{4��Bw�ӟ~�̍:� ���=�;8к��w�]~�����X�_�60����PH�^]�A�Z��"�i����� ��1b��l��$P�l<�T �Q�H� �i\q_�1�j � �^�G��+Kξ)�Uz�k��ɉ��I<#��\?��*�B`�/;Wf��Y�"�H�8�r�6 �_pCi��Ld�_͵){��$3��\0@k��9�Tp��$���o��� ��������d���̵�_ϊ ��0�'J�x�k/��W�������� �]\�砙:� ���/dR�M��0#�����&���w�F���s� S��K��l��p�,��%�V|?�eDH��sK��s���p� �,������ B����ovb!7R����_���M%�����9���b4v�#�\u l��� A����.�<���v���9F;R� ��yw{��LUU�}� 52���%��c����BŚɂj��)S�)��n�A��\�$��Y��r�W���9��z6�C.O�)FfSݑu��`A.��S�^і��;�ғ�� �cv����kc�9�5���^L�Q�`� '�'���N��ʔQ?��#�#��3p�:���a���`7D�y�C\Г܍^��mX���&�����ށ�# ]�_��[�u��"; ��[�յ�4�p�����4��x�~���3�i���< 1ߦ�5�3'k3�)D?v����a��(������@���u�Bʖ�Ud���yH��2��Y�O)�$H���N0NߚA��2F��N3G��b���SӉFQ�L���5:��Yv�&�j�hX�J=u�M�g?�+\����~�G�Ba��j� �Lych��r����� {�� �f�/��S�c�Ô�gྡ� I���dl^�i�������G�b������j9���h����-J�m��f����.�b��... �� �q QB��o��0�5A��>������z2�N��� ��z;A<���%(�� I]����2�|ÿn=Iz�uαpo7v!i`-Z����ɧ[��0U{ݺ��a���Qq!(3�p��x� ��h�������.���;1�=���>��[���#�$ʚ&�o1��o`��;�s�'j1=��{F8���r�WC�3���:|�l>)z�(_mP�")z4Љ��Y�Ѳ6�:���h����l�D�"ԅss��I�&�p*��錰n�r��69��VVՎ��D�;?�H��]�� ��*� =4�=="�<4%�r���g_ VٱH�� �Ǝ��Of�j�Ow��V^:� �P��� �>�qH��?��W�F0���˖�� {\��[�g ��� Q��D3�\�즭���/��(���A�~B�S"��1�'�h�� W�x������c&�c`����`���.���|⦔��$R�`�)�>0j���o��i��= �k!�3c�3Ν�α�>U�cD�2K�m�z���ע��LҰuMH�Vx)%��]7�r����Hf��(���.>v�͜�\f9��H%��^%�@���}]���8���h�E����T D ,� .{��ʟ(��7�GSWv�As唤c�A��(����d�gk\�/�oK�Յq㬗D����ƦM�'�0���ȑΡ�L���V�b����ԡ� �-zT3r#"���6�6;g����A���f�(�˺��x��2�7�ks�J="�ɬu2�l�� �?�C=pu������,�����<.�������wg͋0�exY�#f �.�ي��-�����qp��@.'�)�K嶫,3��QF���&��[7�>"�Do0}e�\@�El.��+#�(R�o*aĀb�Zѿ�[�G�z�hcvͤ~_x��T�����HZ���_�.���ufW�pL�q��@����s�m�LE�3(�E��"��M�"�h�>X7a�D��R� ���,�u���O�� ���x�/L��خM�ؙ���L�*p����T��Y�6���� ��&)����� ���l�]uڇ(�����ql��Y��۸-=V���W��Ok��G�J�:����ͬNm������S�Yv��0[�w��w'���ŋ{q��{q��R�@q���P�w�������5��k�g�#�� E�Kۦz� ���E��3�s$ g%�.����Сf�����9����;9Dq2!�~�, ���A$�4��|���q���Q���_ p���T�6Ѭap(�]�Y����ȾV~.��d������ul�3t��s�-����C��/G1��` ��>�(�In��w��Oy��=���댶7����Z����7�چ�\�&u_��k����d;���Ý��$t|Ƙ��1 ��p�VP���... �Y �b��C��8�x��,���d^jˊ�p̐���M�k�|��``�&.+�E�N!�v*�pʤ���Ϧdrз 4v?���3�> 8�l[@���=%F?��>��eC�������?�@��Y��߸6 $)7����ȩf����}[���pFC �=���BG8�CLBM�=�pE��gR���Yh��K4�D�i��h�z�f,M��c+\Pֵ�� �Jk���� �J�r&�j̩(&���©�?��cܓ���i�K���V[���y��̒����މ^!�q�]g����e��l��~`�%�=+�R��=��G�L�V�5(�I ��w:�9�4�e< f�!R��ݻ���M�U��a����q���m�:�U�~�ЛZ���(=k����U����7Ғ݅�A�תq���B1�� B�I��_j)�mq�-ah���N����U�4�U�W�_�\~]��F�_���R��ˈC`�l j���V�х'JȡyUpLW`J(37���.������:s@�9#04i��顢1d����������[r�&��q�]��l�3Y�@��������#�W�KrE�}R̽�Y�v��q�9��L��L8���Ho�N����ď.�k�=.ΨT�u�~o�?"� �!�#�^�6�2��yἶ*I����H�̶��I{6���À� &L�@���f�,�jsW8o�(&�� d�Bm�J�� =!� ����r������էj2�I���^�ޅ����K�a����'c�w�D�:�(�� ���vբxz���+ɋ81<6-����8�.Y����u�5|�Gیל�����a N�����s��� ��ʴ��7t3&~�A�ēm�^�����2�K�&���'ݽ{@Rv�G- �P��+ �q���� ���j%�6+�7��ظ��-�+�bk��iR�gPVo�l� �<�@��hi��C���}`��J���$��h~�>�/��D;��'�,�ӌ��ޅLU��� �L�:����R��ƷCcݨ"@��*��_=�Ȓ�ß�w= ���A��P�EQڪP��[��k]n�2���uHM3�DLX�By�$6�-��k�k��%��>a�ҳ���(�m�gK��:���u���x���R�B-z8�E�F�H4��[X���'D8R�0�� `s;�n� �y�0y}�Ն� V4�b0��G"w�{\�E2.��=/��v��c�G�StIiO��p����dD߰��[0�@2�V�J�S�~��BQ�l�2\ �.��o�eX��ړ����L*`3�'����3`��I�֦/�sny�">�X9eb/A�\�-���d>1�H���@���㆒k4w�y;�̳> �8F|���To�$��V8sNs�"/M9]�/J�űF��Q�xƸ�-�q���D|aZ�'����9������y0*�j��)� ��t��[a�=��p��qo���0hĶs��O^`�ld6� �l����ؚ��G�жO!SeTY��R����m�?�;�6,Ẉ���Q��e��$~���B�(XӪ��Ƙ�VB�1s*�,������d3 p�ۛ�L9z��... 1��Q��1�Vf4jWO�L ���'�������/�R$���«!,�pF��r�=+��τ�q����qF�-�4b�*�7���qTM�c��3D���������G��#���A�g��Ŋ��̇1�%t6��"d�,�>��`4�1�t \��ї"�ҥ�����u�>";���A�9jA�8�P�̺b������pUmσ3,��f1K��n��x��w�:j �e������d� ��7R�H� �G�}�\|�`�~ς�����`D��1�G4�R�X��2�4[.� �Z����E?g���[5�/����KZ� p�� d�� �� � a�^���L�5�.�M����0qJD�5A�L)ý����;Si���l���V����ȫ�� ���s���y�Ȼ�B2�^c��B��~~�Jz�F����'eA�4gsh�*3p|@-�A�o50kx���ZMY�]���usL�:.�:4r0� �A��J��M���ͪ��ӱ�4������$uڂ��8�ws��=��̶��=zߙ�ߪ���Uh�ȤN#nM~$������|{9R�sT�N�&���ˎ� �[ᯯ��b�dDKuا���+ &��I���s>�yk=6��h�[R��L�i���)8~������2�(t-Ʒ�<���w���f;�D��,����-"s}�M���mt���KkF=j�1T7�d������-1��-����ˁ+E2l��A�5��Ne�_L힌/�T ��(����-ѡαq����U0F�N4�f�肛1ՓL%?N��z�&2�Q"��=����d���M��T�[��P��\���&�bg� ឆs~�����b�rc߈��K��&�?�Y���Ѻ{���P�ƿ�{�'���vߴE���-��]�H�펦SDE{����l��lk@��a������?@d �_�Q�m ��� �s��go�QC:~ZdЩZ~g8Jί`���;&'lY��J�!M�?�(~YR��,<'��,r�X�3�^=c��O�iQ5�Ι t�<���C/� Ri�5 I{+�E��eG���w���l/.v$��@8K�m|� HXyH�G}~�Ĉ2xXcR�y���fɬAB��F�p;Z߷W[��ء ������= �UX j�� ���˫�f]��}�)ɞ�fIC�+�y�.�@������s}�n��8Sx@d>m�1��v�͈n� >G�e�Tƚ*��N4�K�5\PA{�����=�9�~�g]vj�V�w�N���h��MX�R�!�T� �$ ?�bֽ�>Am6J6��{՛�GB�DK�C��<;r�(��1��h_�7D� $����Eq���C����7�����Y1��*6��=��YBB��ta�$x�0�ė�t��Ȗf�$hňE�R/�?U�ܼ���'�du� ���`���&����b��8�Խj��/�P��s��P{��zN*NL�g���ƾ�Ƴ����u]... ���;R��OfI�wso�y���ԼR��p� �1E��I?�M6"K'��}^���Q�� A������l���.�6`��3n��5��⑥[��#$ oN]?4~��u���d���O��+�| �Є:���y�r�G>��>�5�H � ��{��s�J ѭ��G�;��� /<��G�:1;�w\Lv�%Q�u����*삎)C����EQ"��� ��z4#9 BM��j���ɢ\��2j���5=�h�Ҳ���惲�}�� M���(�r�BH�"T0�X�;�H{� EI6�V�dm��>t���/I�;����ܣ6Y�j��۵���Ҏ���#g.�b���s��Ū5"�Q��{����j�h�,���B���s}�W3B��]O��[)�J� ^/Y�M�r�v�77�0��}\�3$��4ʹ�pqB�s�"e��-"$�ڊy���Om�2���iA��$T:%�`��F���,�t�&tL� ~�Ӑ����Z�(�7������8����2^\'������x���%Ҫ����;��S��;���}����� X5�_o�A-)#���x�uY�Y���M;���J�����f�9��Kc�xO4�c�~ ��oo�GO�9���r2����jG�@ Ih�R ��7��� 0` ���+o k=6,�`�J�ܷȇK{�� BYiF�4�/$R=�qSN� ��;4� ����H�`�����!%f�R-� �C�m���(�w����1��Ey��S̆;�'��J0�����.2��;��~'K�X ^R�L�m �.�I�c��n�b�����ђ���k\� ����;y�O�q겝�g��.�]m_�������Z��Zm�������2�̿�����+>w�A�8�aw�_(�*��[@���YK"<8���6q�Z�b�n���j�� i|����F�-; �DI ͑������3 ]���}��W�����e��}�@�6ֆ� �6�ɿ...
G�~����uUUq Hq=�+B��T~4nԈ�k�8�!E�iZ#�T����1��?K��� �\G�����"����,��+8?� z�e�y�w/�V�&�xK���{)�0q<�3�'@$�>�Yς��� (sȩ &�(�jC�C�U�4�4�(�\��J����YjF��D�ڼ�h�F�h������ tW��j9gZIy(����V��;�o͌�� � O�%,\,'`ѫ|F6ԙA��D�O���@�.�{���&���^9U���2c�`}I�iaL�o��3E����' ,��;��� wF��WH�s�~O�/�E20���9�n�= �۔Y��}��6���� ���7����V0�m���P�d�:�VS4Ö!�8Y�KF���~���I63�EQ�9�N����b���?�8J+�6x�l&ٌ"��%-oSj�ʀ��A�f���e�^�aX�6�t���#��m]��ɧ hd��N�z "�P�" �<7W� *���T ���p)?���z��R��Rj&@�I�kVF�JNJ��Z?��s��"(��!k�*��?� i��ie��>��(� �*�\��}������G�VDՊ_���� ��.��G�4�5Q�X�#��_���Tn��4i2���ym4�6T��q٣��XbRu!��;�1wҗ*��u�h����5�A 'a�ي)C �z���ߊQ�Ŕ�ֽ'h`Flg7�KH�= ��\�X'�Ѣ�j�A���h�]<>7)����1@�~%jXƸ%7�����eUT |V�����9�`�{�V�����!PX/'P9�{)�e��HC�a������~c�(�#�j�6:v����쓑���H�� ��< $��U)`��cF��pU�`s;��>��E���!���Cz��7���F6�[�z�cHA��}��n=��ȃ��a��3�ĸ�}����U�F�.g OP}&7� �}�X��fZ.����p�A{�}B�7�V>�ȕ���)p��}w���=DŽ2\7G����n��h�!#:[M�I=Β(�h��\�u�)J1_Q�2�[p����S��u(��Kx�K����g=]B\O��YQ�bME��x��Q�!������C�ܶ�Yg��dO��>浍f��Y �r.���M�>ڠ�(��� �m���lE_�L̃x��� N��p �c�vS��L��.'�y#63Uqg�\�Q��f�����5��ޤ�]v���x�ͪm34I�����K���=�IJ�S�$إx������2( ֽ��úCد|��k9... ��][Ջ 9��VԢJxC���=gd�vO q�[���%�%b} P��K �G{��>���Ӥ��_A�_�0�4RG���k�)��T뱫���+PZ� IT�"x���E25*s%��������Y��'GAFi�>�q�M�ɭy�e�-�����'���K %K�W`ғjDA�\행3�B�^����$�՝�T'���7��Wc��}���"AGl1�7�!��/�k�p����&<�.��Д��y�悆�9&��Y����"V��W����6&��6,����G_D����gᤎd.em[��o5d�5j�Q4����U��N]��]�S6��*��ܭ��)��y"�hhN�Z�Gu;���z�X9�����TC3հXr �>a�5M�;�Z� ���³��DV�`3�ȿ%��L�p�C���}�V�uΙ�Y��w)E2�q[V���Gn�*9va�l*\�^o��� � ��f�����)��������*�6��^+����a0� ^��@ʿ�+���Q�J�<������Ȯ�@�j��l�5.��R��*������������u�O�x�<*DQZ�ŋ[ rY0j~(Q뗵�8�uk�������O3̅�;�wZh���T�;���C��qxKt �~5���x泲�, �:��O�K|��-���W-ڍm "^�|g�D)��Z ��՚��N�e��sŕv�a�Y�4�x8��{���M�֣�ΨjńX�nD�w$,�������ԠB��� 6��tkc�V��? ��@_oR�W�F�2b���,ך��)ݏ82y� Y_�c܅�9�IAd��1Z��UR�h �L��Q�^� qh�oY��A��|,Y B�R�!�� �U4��z`���s1�5�)���O4�����2��h���Z�o���C� �b����zH��S�FM���ɯ��*~��&D�-=:W���)N��%".[�vY��Lj�S&�hX�Z$�7�uQN��3�¶�鎕m�̀>k��L1��)�'��@��>o�Rғ��z��U�H�G��~x��xj���hu( �����{F����%��kJ�E��4��ń��>~%N�iT��k��Ҡ�dk��:U��/���Y�s�i���b���_�o3��D�Rj�$�,��~���RBh�'�ci�I��]�@�aA�0k@ͱG#��| K5����6���v��� '���j�j�K��]d ���ݭ�f���9KjZ�1=�H �s8C������-� �YK���@*��g$9�^H �/��c[^�W����̚)�;,��B��~�0=[n?љ�ۭF;,WZ?��>�^�q��o[s7MwTl�#�q�ⱖl�s��4mt&�W��F���] ? � �txݎoM�8�n9UW=���E)n�Y��4�Z�r���ѐ0K8!bz�aH�ݧv�&���Oe(Q3�x*�f�cl[�?�`#� �����+�~B:���������,�JAL�"�d�$�B��ޥ!��+B'm���KB�d��]��B줡��LN6D����J؏P�iR�]��PA��ɒ^��#{�����ģ��� �xa 岫JR [��R �E�ژ��x�O _�e���?�`���e�N�:�nF����;�s��MP��m�;�MV��o�����~*Q�^K�+ѕ � i]̇��֤�^��&��-�8;a>�LesF3����U�-s�yɪΛj�Y�N������t_C1�\%a����:uO���?ME/I�4T��e�ޕ3�xBטu��uϛ����(D���{a�FM@�暣^EML0�}k�-���M�t]�]dž=�>%{^�3���F��`J�U����rA;w�'6u ��O<�5M%7�ìK*"��&<�]T�� {/X�,k&����ni��zF���_ yg]���G_g������'vT�3����%�@tP��n���*��ex�AA6�}�b*p5�v.���p��� ���c4 �nHd�N�����'n���w�Е���� ~�__���+�y5ӽ�e��h�i���}"�a)���v�d��m���-�L^~7�0�UUr3� �U�렚���+vEҌ�[��\��'"�c�F������� V]�z|���/�b61��X/�ŖI�vOJ�� `S�r��J.f�l����... �hI�g��IwYh�Or�¢�M�UVo�߹2�*Y.�N�f�4��K�/�~�r,�l��GW�L��W�fm=����6�E�K �#g֯�]�S�~��u�LI� �����q��eSf)� 1��%_$��`T�F�fk���}�ui~S����7����P�L1��):&0�� a_#ߨ6�+�#�����ɚ���J�)i$��tE|�MW��5�*�� TLw���A��>D��/l@��$���Q ,�4�l���V��,PXΊVP��D��X����OQ���iǪ 9��6Lrv��0��m[٬.���[K����Ty E�� U�4�]*�,�����L?�I�u�9;�\���V���*�b��qī)�R4L�@���PS ��]/ _^JJ��uFc����hT����}�iw�\rݮ�� �o�&gҳʛ/L30�l,��}��C��wWJ�~�S Δ+y�PJc1c�g����2_�"x�Y��Q��SLB�[����n���Z � ���@C}� ;�aI/���q�2rj> �M�¹�m�6����ޤ������<��/"5�W{1���j��P����~ɰ�FP���߲X�L���D�÷i�/y؋�몴��Xa9��3��zk�1����5��] ��el��-"��@��x����D�7?�0Q�V� �v�{��x� ���wDp�;j^b�b~����2� p;��؝���Y ���1����)�?6����C���?Gn[]7`-�z�zB�����PN�<���>K:����U��D5����%� ��� �j!7��jZ�|!���@��� ڧk=��55B1ݨ�} MK�F����m�� �M�/�³�ir���8_� z�}����1��6 ~��W� �_�6��g�A�?N`�&Fz���vz�N�W�!�3k����0*�F�(�|� �h���3g�o��Q+9��/u�0��G endstream endobj... n���Ҵg�t'�yFw�� f�����4�5�'{�ʇ�~d�DQ2�l��7R϶)� F(�X���+�G�3����$42ҷ��H����-���P#t����+u�'�(��V��W)�� �A�6�,�)���� v2E�`s����@�:G���I+�-�k��x�GS�i�UTu�x!M�Y��qd�`&�p�����}�I-�yG�RY[��R�1��`�������y�Q����h�� L�ZQh�x�O��r�%����6n��h��g\�F|�@���m��(���_�w�Ac���C4�\�u���J��Z�Ф���c�da�E^�����a�ʟ�r6���.+����x����:/1߆",a?�K57�X��T��J�����J3Ѵ�e�|��Ew�O���%�jp 'UR��(x����)��D��!����d��)�&��L� ��y��o�XK���>����f��2��B���@�&��-�ִd���:]��/f�N~K=��6!+N���i���rwY��Yh�Y<pf�)�ErF<�k���: b2?e��20N5�P�U�S�q".�v�tDG����mz� �y��T~��ߤ= ;D�e&���U �cI�[d����3���ە|;_t������[<4�R��i��k�� Jfdw҈N�y���[���<�]7�M�b�ⱹSZ$�'h�0�]�k¤� �=`c�ˡe���+��#�����4�,���v����F8C;-_���}�8a�m�b���o��'�������%�'*��ώ�[>T�d�ъq&`R�P ��28WA@cR� e3��6 ��1z����@�A����n�A�݊�����\?�=���i��C=X���w>�Ц���&O���$i����C/B�У ��G��\Y�u�KX��)�5�� �B�RO�8��ߣ�jy<~����s�cC���m]X!7�o��:k�� �Bx� ����~~&!f �Q��Ί/�U�KXe��\�t�n��!,�0Xᙔ��T ��H�(7�H���Ce_L�^͖�}����O<�%��rS���>��� �y�Q��2K�W���S� �*lA���V�A=��И�t�7(}�����V�2k�1l�I��C>�g ��g���И��BQH��b����Pϳy�"�`�� z� T�膯��l ,�8}?y �����'k)�� x2z=�����D�P�gS�u#����&����RƲ锞�s��W]7cK'�²�-4�[<���O9�� Mx���#a� '&�L=����... |?Y�iv�� �O{�̛UG� &�]� M�~��mn)�#k��~B?k��h��� P���x*�}> �B&�j֣�Ө�0�x�w.���Hw ��߿� �M��hFt�B���;e�1_�M !�����\R���1��|ݟT�:*�Р�F��Hm�P����/�cH��e�/�V��.�Ƹji|�R��Ї���)�V�Җ�b�!��H*���ب�s�A� �o}y0o`�y�I����WJ������� =��-���?^?ҷ���^�I�@�l��>4 PsBSy�f"���pO,����Z$�峅,ҴW������N���� ���k��g����кY��r�^[u�ɗ��h5� �[lg)���:�g]��>Z�g��3��u������ �#1��7-�����}���x���y|9��}g���r�Ħ�_�3F�W�� ��/�tA��}��HAq{�4K34q�W��;̩D��X��310� {5^*�N\e{?�D�O?t��>��]�F�4�;��m� ��KȎ l��}ƓE�M���YA��nNm ?��*8�����*�1+/I�H��R�x�,o�˽�fPs}ToUi�rvbD} H |]3g� �W<��su`~YM�(ټ�Nr��y(C�Q%�(w�(5�bP� ��8��g��(���t�j٨���(�ΛA��J}��_r�m����W�=z�J�8�a?
�@{c�9;�>�}S�`S�6��VB���pp��q��U���|���L�ד�끕y��d�D죩T:o"��)F\���Z�L�q�(Ywnk*�����& �I��K�nC*�]�{��g��� 5��A0��"��X`��:��j�a;�;e� ,�b��4��Yy�vQ܌���?ہ�t ������2�#��m��3?>�܍0�Ar ��P(+�dK��@��=Ev�ÚS_:p}��M�آL�P "3��sB� ��8�[��j�g�����j�� ��x7αPw`ӽkQ��1���J k�Gh:=9�1�ɤ�}�} B!�`)�4~/JG[<����ۻ<�d1,kE���)��b��[�vx���g~�QT�����&e,)��,�.y��?�k)}� @�N���_eܶ��I�� X�s�R=��[��)�y]���k�'Q����:���H��� Ng�ٔ�W��Q����S���qӮ �g��u��?��T�փ���;Ƭt���]㦧����p�h83���{\bY~�i�Ŕ�{�f�&�,��Yy�n� �����Xx�3a�\��T�U&���茻�\ ,v�Xxy��/��|hGB ���|_�X)��Y�&%Wº }tqc�K���GqE�ɚ��G,<:�es�� ���I� �X�O� �(~ ѦL�����J]s ��͚��td�"�T�y�T�zF��m�Ti�/7>������7D�5��"�����(��J�����������h��Dr��: ��/!�y���@9��x<� �c�+��⼰[Ekq�3q��|mw~i�}�(7�'�s�߹:�Nk�ߊɽ?TŽ�Vn��'E�֓$���[��*� �. ٢gi����d�Cx%DiU��K�*k�`j.��i��ع�/W���hb��$�X+�7���Ԡ6l$f�_C'����:?%�S���S�(n� N8�݇@���u� e�_���>�fō��d��'�dn]������)���^迼��1�&9<Ҝ����K��t��#�q�����DZ�dT�;��?<��N*���܊s�tgdG��5����Im4%�\��� �`�!�ݼ+BKX�+Wa���4�qN�ު�0� Ѩ� m�s+?����;��gd�r�����k����(��'�a�B���R�ƒ|�n�7 �{ ��)�a��}n���j�փ�����_W�s�KpuhM<���:3o�����Q;��R@Y�9$� ��S�r��"5�(�&�B���$��}ꜥ���vA�yQ*x5A�pu�Q$_n����Ԛ�X?��L/���.���pLr�L��^�y,�CT�(5R���J��87{�qǾ@�.�.US_#�9��gME���@N.��W��c�k��g��I�r 2�N��:m%)�.��ݜ:]����_�A2c�k+�_0���qi�m���f+����ᩇJ}�7�`k���@��s,�`W�f���h��@f�)�M .�K iAx�Ӌ��5�J1�M�� %梪R�$� �ǂ��Po=��W��x� ��Z��f�ڮ��vqo� 녡O.{<݁S��>6QWV�>�)܇z�t?w1��ϕ� ]�63{�+� ������ˊ�*������$WQ����pf�%8b~}o���1"����CQC��_�}�6����k<�a�(4�5�D���? �'��z�J�3��Xq@VnVu<��̅[�[���F���6kt'f�w�Nm��!��;�~Z�&���a� Z����#���XK \,�m��l�Z;�q*,"ˮ�GLE����!��?F�| �~::�����qu�G��k��Ij[ļ��a~(a>�F���]��W��T��\?��P��id��qm1��њ�7s5]�����>�=����\-7�@�9rW?�J#_�SrT�X��Gw5l��:��c*��{mT�z����o#�P��(�s�n��E�ϒ5,�IH��Y=�Zu��P��?�a\�*9�D���=�Uj;yyeD�Cq� �q����� ��s��כ�){C-OlJw���]�B'���~h?��7�`�UB)C�pa�v�튗I+�-��}fhRPTA�amvp��� b������@�/ɿQ������y�u)������Z|�� V���mt�e"R���N'�`=�B6�����|wĻ��M�hG� v���<�Ӡ��^W�st�NM�5�Y� E����Ja"G��gue�o=��(�u���"_� �q>����[ �q ��W�B<9��הj�0��X%)'у �^;�tus7�$����/�gi�I'�U��!ڌ]<����bq�:�Hh�� ����� �������S��7�����W�����^"�� r��W�x<^7��w�v�]�k��<���G�-I$�z���m64l����q\f�4ĸ�`���'�'�䚴d �EF��G��T�C ����?��� ��7��)|�~����C�ysΎ����uJ�t��VV"�2���O)�� Ѿ��U}cGw�v9�P�5�\FqG !�З� � k2�B$��{�� T�A���ìu0 ��������&?��oV����^�O��;�$���ڸ�h�T����9�DRV��>�YsQu�L������S��m��z ;��� �)`4r,�INi^�ȷ��;����8G`bN �Ba ͨZ���X��טv����� 3���a��Hđ!�l &gk��&a���)n�Kx>��[D�s�/L�9�(x�Nj��V���i���/���?ozgY[�&E�(�0����C"�r�!Feq��C��E�(��ݰ�sV�=?�ԳB�X���rD�C/��Cٚ�����F�Ra �~����7w����N���&>rɯ��8�&�db*�!�EA.����S�� y�"��4e�#��-��u���]�^�w��E��,�Zu�/[��Z�$�g�[c�}�b�U�������9�-�k�Z���"�#�V@%�=��0��'�"'�s��.��]l�\��b���Ë�`&�����0��χ�NJ^��?�R�.vt8�F��\�e�x�8w)G���C�7tގ��Fr�7gA�... o�y ���#�@����{�ˮВt4�k�9"��Z�ĝ[��u(I�k�&�����S��q�?����]O��m^�O�]��]j�v10��a(!�>�G'�"{��2�p�kb�f:HVG�RO���(�z����Iϣ��Rg�_���c��N '��y�I�w�%��i�#����<���bD�_MQʼesL7ښ w��E�[�� � Sߍ�4ddГ�l�S����݆����姗�ڏ,EZ��FծB��:�)��|7g,���e� ^�nKfe ��� ���':�=�pD�2#4�k�_L� ��L�e�M� ln�0mר������a��| �����*�sd��h��d~9��?�� X��P['=\=lR�9�X`r���|Yw�/h��_5�����q�� xqۍ��kKPF��b��.�f���z�>��H���#� ����V��@� �[��Nj���6�M��+�1�"w�-�D'L6\�r��W1������t�(�N�,G+����r vޫ����e2�%�;�hd&���_��0�,9jM����� ��ï�I�n���L��.�N�/�M��<�����l��܄������.���R�J���4t�D=�k �����[�5c2���/�� �F f�L� �ÿd��Dg01Z?�\�ُ#�*�6�#�2��WA:۠�{P��ǀ�v;��v��u9�� �M}�Ib�=&C��a�[�$-��l�9'� �vc�:�C�9=D_�����=3 ��R�ub�a8A7|�I�69E�"�Գo�\�x��8 �6���"�����> b9~�r��M��T��bv���pۨIz�70"�u|�����Ŀ�Ě8���; ;B\�Fī�e���L5�xu:�Ѱ�4�J��S8���=�`��w�*qb ���h���b�f�1`4e��:��3�ӎ��m@$J#|�C��4��eͯ�0���N�Ci��х�"8 �<��Z�5��tK�o2}��+r��cȑ���\D<��w�e�E��pIH�D��� �W~G[��L���Z"WE�� +˽�yb<��(vwM6ǚM�;�B�a�!��G�d�ݏ�t��2Bw��������l^�ү~p$����|g�Eh��:�щ�8���;X�h�?��8a2Bs<1�%�W��T��=Wm5��|�éK'��|�9��Uz`���e2������= *�fWV˓u(Đ���Gމ��1J���.�)Sq��n��M��&%\�ť��e��F(�������fx-b�ލ°E���� [mܻR.���|�魖�th?Q0�e����*�W�a����l3L%�V��+�b������n�Eޫϋ�0ţ.��ud?��ڹh��'��D�e�l�vi���f��4���R���W*�3�I�Ѥ��3a&��;��՞�Ҷ�ĸ���==��X����Ў����>;�@B�k�>�e�"�C����Z���ݑ�M�8|^2ݔ&�tQ���Ce_L�ȓ���83���\�if�<... #`�F��Z�w1�qY��3�ј�7]���FAϢ������� `0� &�kQ���p�p����πӑ� d�Ɏ�F��S*3$Z&��Wֺ��[���*��X�p��� @a � ][1q�B�?ٟ��2��_V���jmWe�Tp�/���R鲼���u �d�<���[��z�`#;��\��2��T ��,�" 7� 82�*8;����7K0z,ch��(u��.���I�&�/� ~$E|5�j50� �!)�(���6��J e�o~�0Φ���\��!ʀ�CKQ�>�`�( �������ť�2�u��8cͨ�������#�Gn�cmOX��\�3F��[�~���88�{��7�A�|�}NM/�M+ �v�G.'�S���bf���7$>�&�6�.ƁpP�V��Je��KsO���祜�x �d%�X{ -(��p�p6�g�y��+i�v�$q��Ҧ� �aG�iO�O��kś�/�vI���UÈ�)UtvA��,���Tsx�����35�E~�S������&��/|M�l˰�CjAE�Z�T�F�3rB?�G�Z��h~y%���G�澃p'�2�ܐx �Z=X��� ;@�� C�f~ �x�����F���K�|=�{c9�ۣ�ސ ʼ��������l�cy5 �o�*ҋw�$��}Ք|tIt� C��ܯ�b?��� F�o���%�b����>~�&m.Ȣ�II;Ơ� ��x�7�/"���O�$��kѶ�ڶm۶m۶m۶m۶m��}�!�J�H& )o��#<ŢPIS���"K���8o�7�*D����b�LjKd>�����v@^��?Q�I�b%H�g� aɊ����d�i��9F� ��F�I/��+���r����v3����Dm]�&qI�Õ+3M�.x8s�B���p8���$1����~��N�d�YYf`[ �φ�5aE.Ȫj�d�:�J�W�?B�4��nq3��eh!l�oV���C�r��mF�l�vͫɝ>��+��¿�?��Gy��89��u=�Y����Y�� ��4�=&���u��xP!�����.X�����o}�����0����.\0��NԠ��hnm���4Od�@zI@��1�ț�T��i��劰M|��D�mi�H�oi��U��|e�3F&���cR��V�o?Z������������EnobU��i�fN��Upf�gb��(%h����ҏ��p=�=��$���-{�xv�[��{��� ���ҊaZ5�܇m��R4]A��?�z��f\... ,��H�Kc�2jZ�Z���#7G{嶦 =�����'s���R���5�*�pa�m8|�Ҧ�0ȭ����k/��J��ڊ��Mel?��A�ZÞ1'���e��6EI� /�����i���ɑ ����[��*֗DgZf��)���7'�- � ��B��X�J�B��|��4�?�Yʦ!)�B�����[��-�%R��ӹ��_LȖ�N�KL�6���3�.�5!��'�A���?`�[ѕ���z�m�w6�#�h8��Q�� �#4����E b�m���Ӧ1����7��!��@�s����C��e�y���� ��M�/>Nk��R{.�v :p�^�3�L�¥'��c���vޠE�����[,Bv��-�hH ;�Wюz���Ƃi�%P�Fl� M��"����qKy�C��lW#:�WF>賏�[� �?.�r�Y"�=�V��X�u[�� �t��)g.�0�� (�x�� ���/����cl���B��@2d�1�-����V����Q����u�����q7j�;�2��cg �h}L���k��hS��4��6���`�e��TxT���eW?����FW�O���>̰��\9��{ɛ��t��l�P�kO����Q�ۭtEJ�%�W%��E������ ��d��_��CR��!eϫ��.�W��]�2�⮣�����T�Q$#�%�~$2��Ы/���iJZݿ�ѷ@�`I%� ���I��5��}� �� "l��=�����ce�q���7X�����o�Ζ=wJ��&)M9[�)J�N-p��̇IWޢ!�P��Փq���s�����%}�e�b � �*�!dO��g#��3=$��B�J+���o����gx"tg��'2x㣿v�l(A��c-PP�u}:��+{�/Mt n�́�}��w�ئ#k�-fZ6x+��w��p��)>D�շ^�p���Ǔ��y�î�������{�S��E�~���0@\��������;3��\�r������o���S�7��t:���fN�>�c��8{�!���=��B 0 �o�`S����;��v�.�>��ΈC��`wnaܺ�~����m��9 �G��{0Zd�W�O�J`�o���:MQ�( ����Gw[ 2W��� ¶��4o~O��� �B�Ƃ R_��)va��p*�9g�i���͙Q�psI�P���^�tO��ǡ�������̱J��8R���ȼ��5��eb>�n������A���� �!�I��Y1�=i����0ָ��iN#�e=�,�k��N:�!O�rU"��61���_r��5� �,>�F�������뽺...
People Also Search
- [2004.05773] Generating Fact Checking Explanations - arXiv.org
- PDF Generating Fact Checking Explanations - arXiv.org
- [2410.15669] Learning to Generate and Evaluate Fact-checking ...
- [2004.05773] Generating Fact Checking Explanations
- [2112.06924] Generating Fluent Fact Checking Explanations with ...
- Evaluating Evidence Attribution in Generated Fact Checking Explanations
- Generating Fact Checking Explanations - ACL Anthology
- [2511.20233] REFLEX: Self-Refining Explainable Fact-Checking via ...
- REFLEX: Self-Refining Explainable Fact-Checking via Disentangling Truth ...
- Learning to generate and evaluate fact-checking explanations with ...
ArXivLabs Is A Framework That Allows Collaborators To Develop And
arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website. Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them. Have an idea for a project that will add v...
Both Individuals And Organizations That Work With ArXivLabs Have Embraced
Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them. Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs. Most existing work on automated fact checking is concerned w...
This Paper Provides The First Study Of How These Explanations
This paper provides the first study of how these explanations can be generated automatically based on available claim context, and how this task can be modeled jointly with veracity prediction. Our results indicate that optimising both objectives at the same time, rather than training them separately, improves the performance of a fact checking system. The results of a manual evaluation further su...
The Current Research Landscape In Automated Fact Checking Is Comprised
The current research landscape in automated fact checking is comprised of systems that estimate the veracity of claims based on available metadata and evidence pages. Datasets like LIAR Wang (2017) and the multi-domain dataset MultiFC Augenstein et al. (2019) provide real-world benchmarks for evaluation. There are also artificial datasets of a larger scale, e.g., the FEVER Thorne et al. (2018) dat...
(2019), And Artificial Data – 68.46 FEVER Score (label Accuracy
(2019), and artificial data – 68.46 FEVER score (label accuracy conditioned on evidence provided for ‘supported’ and ‘refuted’ claims) Stammbach and Neumann (2019), the task of automating fact checking remains a significant and poignant... A prevalent component of existing fact checking systems is a stance detection or textual entailment model that predicts whether a piece of evidence contradicts ...