Ex Giant Questions Brian Daboll Firing And Compares Dart To Mvp

Bonisiwe Shabane

-Nov 17, 2025, 5:24 AM

ex giant questions brian daboll firing and compares dart to mvp

The New York Giants have had a roller coaster season in 2025. It’s been filled with ups and downs, highs and lows, and a whole lot of losing. The emergence of rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart has been a big one, with New York seemingly finding their first franchise quarterback since the legendary Eli Manning. But injuries, poor talent, and coaching around the Ole Miss product have left him to carry the load by himself. Head coach Brian Daboll was fired midseason after his third consecutive 2-8 start, despite the positive development of Dart. Kyle Rudolph (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)

Kyle Rudolph believes the New York Giants may have been a little too quick in firing head coach Brian Daboll. Daboll, who was the 2022 NFL Coach of the Year, was fired earlier in the week, midway through his fourth season with the Giants. The firing came after the Giants lost four consecutive games, including blowing major leads in the fourth quarter against the Denver Broncos (19 points) and the Chicago Bears (10 points). After experiencing great success in his first season in New York in 2022, the Giants registered the second-worst winning percentage (.250) over his final two-and-a-half seasons. However, there appeared to be some optimism in recent weeks after rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart was inserted into the lineup. The Giants managed to pull off upset wins over the Los Angeles Chargers and Philadelphia Eagles in two of Dart's first three starts.

Robert Griffin III and Colin Cowherd react to the New York Giants firing HC Brian Daboll, discuss Caleb Williams’ clutch performance vs. the Giants, and whether or not Aaron Rodgers and the Pittsburgh Steelers are collapsing. Former NFL quarterback Dan Orlovsky said Monday he believed that the New York Giants should have given head coach Brian Daboll another year because of his budding relationship with Jaxson Dart. The Giants fired Daboll after the team blew another fourth-quarter lead. This time, it came against the Chicago Bears. Orlovsky said on ESPN the Giants may have jumped the gun early on the Daboll era.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE SPORTS COVERAGE ON FOXNEWS.COM Then-Los Angeles Rams quarterback Dan Orlovsky (8) during warmups prior to the game against the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field on Aug. 31, 2017. (Jeff Hanisch/USA TODAY Sports) The New York Giants have officially decided to move on from now-former head coach Brian Daboll after a disappointing three-plus-year run. His dismissal comes on the heels of yet another fourth-quarter meltdown that included rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart's fourth concussion evaluation.

Daboll's relentless willingness to dial up designed runs that put Dart in harm's way amid a lost campaign presumably factored into the former's firing. The play-calling was emblematic of someone fighting for his job, which proved true, albeit futile. However, health aside, Daboll has been instrumental to Dart's rapid ascension as an organizational centerpiece since replacing Russell Wilson as the Giants' starting signal-caller. You could argue that alone should've saved the 2022 Coach of the Year from getting canned, and yet, here we are. Besides winning, Dart's development ought to be the Giants' top priority, right? He plays the most important position in football, which they've struggled to fill since franchise legend Eli Manning retired in 2020.

His long-term growth is more important than any short-term success the club hoped to enjoy this season. On one hand, it's understandable why the Giants chose to part ways with Daboll. They went 20-40-1 under him; he had ample time to right the ship. But on the other hand, his tenure was only just beginning after finally getting a handpicked gunslinger to work with. Brian Daboll’s best hope at sticking around as Giants coach was rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart. Dart leaving Sunday’s game with a concussion was the start of their latest collapse, the final straw that got the 50-year-old coach fired Monday in the middle of his fourth season at the helm.

After Russell Wilson took over, the Giants were able to get down to the Bears’ 1-yard line but couldn’t punch it in, and Daboll settled for a field goal to go up 20-10 with... The Giants were able to force the Bears into a turnover on downs on the Chicago 43-yard line with 8:41 left, but with Dart gone, the Wilson-led offense had two penalties and ran the... Chicago then went on a nine-play, 91-yard touchdown drive, jump-started by a 20-yard Caleb Williams pass to tight end Colston Loveland on a third-and-10 at the Bears’ 26-yard line. The New York Giants fired head coach Brian Daboll on Monday after a 2-8 start to the 2025 NFL season and a string of fourth-quarter collapses that left ownership exhausted and fans demanding change. Offensive coordinator Mike Kafka was named the interim head coach while GM Joe Schoen remains in place and will lead the search for Daboll’s permanent replacement. On ESPN’s Monday pregame show, analyst Dan Orlovsky made his stance clear, arguing it could be a mistake to pull Daboll given the rapport he was building with rookie QB Jaxson Dart and the...

"I'm of the belief this is a mistake by the New York Giants," Orlovsky said. "It was clear that the quarterback and head coach had something going together. The fourth-quarter leads are obviously something that you're sitting there and killing yourself over, (but) this team lost its best player (Malik Nabers), and then they lost probably their second or third best, certainly... The fact that they had built these leads should warrant something." "And the reality is this defense that's got a gajillion dollars or early draft picks had 10-point fourth quarter leads four different times this year, and they couldn't find ways to secure the lead... And so, as much as we want to sit there and say Daboll didn't get it done, a lot of the highly prized defensive talent didn't get it done as well."

Yannick Peterhans / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images The New York Giants finally found a reason to get this right. That reason's name is Jaxson Dart, and in the end, Brian Daboll's head coaching job depended on how the Giants' leadership viewed his chances of being the right guy to journey into the future... They decided Daboll's road has ended, firing him Monday, according to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport. Of course, this could've happened irrespective of having found a franchise quarterback. Daboll, who came to the Giants after being a star offensive coordinator with the Buffalo Bills, wasn't winning enough games.

It was exhilarating, chaotic and impossible to sustain. Rookie Jaxson Dart did something no one else could: he revitalized an apathetic Giants fanbase in his first start. But as a fearless, freewheeling gunslinger, that also meant provoking the football gods with his style of play. After improbable wins over the Chargers in his debut and the division-leading Eagles two weeks later, Dart kept making big plays -- with his legs and, when things broke down (which was often), with... Dart was so good, so soon, that he looked like he was going to save Brian Daboll's job. But that style -- more Cam Skattebo than your typical NFL quarterback -- caught up with Dart and Daboll in Week 10.

The Giants blew another fourth-quarter lead, this time against the Bears. The rookie left Chicago in concussion protocol. And the coach was fired midway through his fourth season. We all knew that Daboll faced long odds to survive the season. In January, some three months before the team traded back into the first round to take Dart, Giants co-owner John Mara said of righting a franchise that has had just one winning season since...

Ex Giant Questions Brian Daboll Firing And Compares Dart To Mvp

People Also Search

The New York Giants Have Had A Roller Coaster Season

Kyle Rudolph Believes The New York Giants May Have Been

Robert Griffin III And Colin Cowherd React To The New

CLICK HERE FOR MORE SPORTS COVERAGE ON FOXNEWS.COM Then-Los Angeles

Daboll's Relentless Willingness To Dial Up Designed Runs That Put