University of Kwazulu-Natal

Articles Mislead On Us Weather Data Global Warming Fact Check

Bonisiwe Shabane
-
articles mislead on us weather data global warming fact check

"96% of U.S Climate Data Is Corrupted, Study Shows," says a July 23, 2023 headline from Slay News, a website that AFP has previously fact-checked for spreading misinformation. The article says: "Much of the panic-inducing claims of a 'climate emergency' we hear from in the media, often supported with scary red and fire orange-colored weather maps, are mostly based on corrupted data." Similar claims spread online -- including in German -- as summer 2023 saw high temperatures globally. NASA announced in mid-August that July was the hottest month since records began in 1880 (archived here). The Slay News story cites a 2022 report (archived here) from the Heartland Institute, a US nonprofit that promotes "free-market solutions to social and economic problems." AFP has previously fact-checked the group's climate claims. "This report finds approximately 96 percent of US temperature stations fail to meet what the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) considers to be 'acceptable,' uncorrupted placement," says the study, which has not been...

"These findings strongly undermine the legitimacy and the magnitude of the official consensus on long-term climate warming trends." An ocean temperature decrease between 2013-2022 proves global warming is a hoax. Misleading. The claim is based on cherry-picked data and evidence shows global warming is real. AAP FACTCHECK - A small decrease in ocean temperatures over eight years does not disprove global warming, despite claims being made online. A graph based on data from the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) that shows global ocean temperature data from 2014 to 2022 is being used as evidence to undermine the science of...

While the graph indicates a 0.02C decrease over the period, long-term data shows a clear warming trend. A Nov. 29 Facebook post (direct link, archive link) shows a graph of U.S. Climate Reference Network temperature data from 2005 to 2024. The data in the graph is fairly scattered and it does not include a trend line. "The U.S.

Climate Reference Network record from 2005 shows no obvious warming during this period," reads part of the post's caption. The post, which was shared more than 300 times in two weeks, links to an article that also shows the graph and makes the same claim. More from the Fact-Check Team: How we pick and research claims | Email newsletter | Facebook page U.S. Climate Reference Network data does show warming since 2005, continuing a trend that stretches back decades earlier. A digital billboard displays an unofficial temperature, July 17, 2023, in Phoenix.

Cities across the United States and around the world are grappling with ways to protect people from extreme heat as global temperatures rise each year. (AP) Fox News host Jesse Watters recycled a claim climate change deniers have been making for years. "Hottest year on record, huh?" Watters asked Jan. 31 on "Jesse Watters Primetime," his skepticism apparent. He expressed doubts about the longevity and accuracy of global temperature records, then criticized the legitimacy of National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s temperature data collection.

NOAA, the federal agency that studies weather, oceans and the climate, is "putting the thermometers in the cities … on concrete and asphalt," Watters said. "You ever been to the city in the summer?" he asked. "You ever walk around in your bare feet on a city sidewalk in August? It’s hot. That’s where we’re putting the thermometers to measure the world’s temperature. On little heat islands."

By Ayesha Tandon, Leo Hickman, Cecilia Keating, and Robert McSweeney. Design by Tom Prater. A “critical assessment” report commissioned by the Trump administration to justify a rollback of US climate regulations contains at least 100 false or misleading statements, according to a Carbon Brief factcheck involving dozens of... The 140-page report — “A critical review of impacts of greenhouse gas emissions on the US climate” — was published by the US Department of Energy (DoE) on 23 July, just days before the... The executive summary of the controversial report inaccurately claims that “CO2-induced warming might be less damaging economically than commonly believed”. It also states misleadingly that “excessively aggressive [emissions] mitigation policies could prove more detrimental than beneficial”.

In September, Politico published an article titled “How a major DOE report hides the whole truth about climate change.” In October, I rebutted that article in a two–part essay. Today’s post provides further vindication of the Department of Energy (DOE) report, A Critical Review of Impacts of Greenhouse Gas Emissions on the U.S. Climate. Four reporters — Benjamin Storrow, Chelsea Harvey, Scott Waldman, and Paula Friedrich — co-authored the Politico article. Climate scientists John Christy, Judith Curry, Steve Koonin, Ross McKitrick, and Roy Spencer co-authored the DOE report. In August, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposed to repeal the Obama-era EPA’s 2009 Greenhouse Gas Endangerment Finding.

That Finding supplied the foundational statutory and scientific rationales for the climate policy regulatory agendas of the Obama and Biden administrations. The EPA’s repeal proposal includes a brief “climate science discussion” that frequently cites the DOE report. The Politico article aimed to undermine the case for Endangerment Finding repeal by discrediting the DOE report as a “political plan” rather than a “scientific exercise.” Politico claims the DOE report “cherry-picks mainstream research and omits context,” “relies on outdated studies,” “cites analyses that were not peer reviewed,” and “revives debunked arguments.” As my rebuttal pieces show, Politico’s criticisms repeatedly... Today’s post further debunks the Politico reporters’ “omits context” allegation. A Jan.

29 Facebook post (direct link, archive link) shows heat maps of the U.S. and makes a series of claims about climate and weather. "Global cooling was real from 1944 to 1982," reads text in the post. "Global warming was real from 1983 to 2006. Since 2007, sea ice has been expanding at both poles. 2021 was the coldest winter ever recorded in Antarctica.

The Earth goes through cycles which aren't caused by man." The post also states that January 1990 was warmer than 2025 and asks "a climate hoaxer" for an explanation. The post was shared more than 2,000 times in two weeks. More from the Fact-Check Team: How we pick and research claims | Email newsletter | Facebook page

People Also Search

"96% Of U.S Climate Data Is Corrupted, Study Shows," Says

"96% of U.S Climate Data Is Corrupted, Study Shows," says a July 23, 2023 headline from Slay News, a website that AFP has previously fact-checked for spreading misinformation. The article says: "Much of the panic-inducing claims of a 'climate emergency' we hear from in the media, often supported with scary red and fire orange-colored weather maps, are mostly based on corrupted data." Similar claim...

"These Findings Strongly Undermine The Legitimacy And The Magnitude Of

"These findings strongly undermine the legitimacy and the magnitude of the official consensus on long-term climate warming trends." An ocean temperature decrease between 2013-2022 proves global warming is a hoax. Misleading. The claim is based on cherry-picked data and evidence shows global warming is real. AAP FACTCHECK - A small decrease in ocean temperatures over eight years does not disprove g...

While The Graph Indicates A 0.02C Decrease Over The Period,

While the graph indicates a 0.02C decrease over the period, long-term data shows a clear warming trend. A Nov. 29 Facebook post (direct link, archive link) shows a graph of U.S. Climate Reference Network temperature data from 2005 to 2024. The data in the graph is fairly scattered and it does not include a trend line. "The U.S.

Climate Reference Network Record From 2005 Shows No Obvious Warming

Climate Reference Network record from 2005 shows no obvious warming during this period," reads part of the post's caption. The post, which was shared more than 300 times in two weeks, links to an article that also shows the graph and makes the same claim. More from the Fact-Check Team: How we pick and research claims | Email newsletter | Facebook page U.S. Climate Reference Network data does show ...

Cities Across The United States And Around The World Are

Cities across the United States and around the world are grappling with ways to protect people from extreme heat as global temperatures rise each year. (AP) Fox News host Jesse Watters recycled a claim climate change deniers have been making for years. "Hottest year on record, huh?" Watters asked Jan. 31 on "Jesse Watters Primetime," his skepticism apparent. He expressed doubts about the longevity...