Analysis Grading Every Seahawks First Round Pick Reddit

Bonisiwe Shabane

-Nov 17, 2025, 8:48 PM

analysis grading every seahawks first round pick reddit

Stability in the NFL has grown to be quite rare. Whether it's at the quarterback position or a person of higher power, head coach, and/or general manager, owners have seemingly grown impatient. The so-called "microwave results" have taken over. Looking for immediate success after drafting a rookie quarterback or potentially hiring a new head coach is impractical. The Seattle Seahawks have been one of the rare examples of stability in the NFL. Even though they moved off Pete Carroll this offseason, he and John Schneider both began their journeys in Seattle in 2010.

Throughout a lot of turmoil that transpired, the head coach, general manager, and quarterback were the consistent pillars of a franchise that found ways to win games. It is no surprise that the steadiness of this organization directly resulted in multiple playoff appearances, two Super Bowl field trips, and one Super Bowl victory. Their ideology was to build within, which required them to be successful in the draft. Back in 2010, the Seahawks were sort of given an advantage when hiring Pete Carroll because of his relativeness in the field of college football recruiting. Given the dominance he established at USC, he was not only familiar with players on his roster but, of those who played at a high level with other universities. As a result of that, the Seahawks were able to build a generational defense which later on claimed the name, the Legion of Boom.

Many have argued that since the departure of the Legion of Boom, Pete Carroll got power-crazed, and lost his grasp on the college football landscape, resulting in poor draft-day decisions. Primarily, early on in a round where you are supposed to be drafting a certified starter at their respective position. Also, known as Day 1 of the NFL Draft. It is befitting that the success of the Seattle Seahawks' first-round selections emulated that of a rollercoaster ride during Pete Carroll and John Schneider's 14-year tenure together. Dating back to 2010, we examine and grade every first-round selection. The Seattle Seahawks' 2025 NFL draft is complete, and it was apparently much better than the 2024 draft.

We won't know that for sure for a few years, of course. Some players chosen on Day 3 might become stars, like Richard Sherman and Kam Chancellor did. Players selected on Day 1 or 2 might not work out. Let's hope every single choice the Seahawks made in the draft works out, but the truth is some of the players won't make the team. Seattle, like every team, only has 53 players on the roster, and suddenly having nine of them be rookies is not logical. Some of the draftees are probably going to fall to the practice squad.

But how did each pick grade? And how might each help the Seahawks sooner or later? Here are some truths and some guesses. John Schneider did the most un-Schneider thing ever and took an interior offensive lineman in the first round. Plus, he didn't just take any given guard; he arguably got the best guard in the entire draft. Zabel is strong and athletic and a perfect fit in offensive coordinator Klint Kubiak's scheme.

Bold prediction: This is, admittedly, not so bold. Zabel will start at left guard in Week 1 of the 2025 season. He will be a Pro Bowler for multiple consecutive years beginning in 2026. John Schneider came to the Seattle Seahawks in 2010 as general manager and eventually became executive vice president. It was his second stint in the Great Northwest. He had served as director of player personnel for one year in 2000.

Most of the in-between time was spent in Green Bay, where he was instrumental in helping build the Packers’ last Super Bowl champion in 2010. Schneider was involved in the drafts that landed Jordy Nelson, Greg Jennings, Clay Matthews, A.J. Hawk, T.J. Lang, Josh Sitton, B.J. Raji, and a quarterback who kept slipping in the first round in 2005. His name was Rodgers.

Since coming to Seattle, Schneider has overseen fifteen drafts. At that time, he had made 12 first-round sections. Seattle did not have a first-round pick in five of those years. In two of them, they had two picks in Round One. Let’s do a quick rundown of those first-rounders. We’ll assign a grade based on overall production and focus mainly on the player’s contributions as a Seahawk, not on what they may have accomplished for other franchises.

We will also briefly take into account missed opportunities. If Schneider had a better player available, the selection might have been downgraded, but not very much. You can always nitpick and find a player drafted after your guy who went on to have a better career.

Analysis Grading Every Seahawks First Round Pick Reddit

People Also Search

Stability In The NFL Has Grown To Be Quite Rare.

Throughout A Lot Of Turmoil That Transpired, The Head Coach,

Many Have Argued That Since The Departure Of The Legion

We Won't Know That For Sure For A Few Years,

But How Did Each Pick Grade? And How Might Each