Commanders 2025 Draft Grades Report Cards For Every Player Taken

Bonisiwe Shabane

-Nov 17, 2025, 9:07 AM

commanders 2025 draft grades report cards for every player taken

The Washington Commanders were one win away from a Super Bowl appearance last season. Dan Quinn's team will look to find the necessary reinforcements in the NFL draft to secure that win and one more next season. Jayden Daniels shined in his rookie campaign, solidifying himself as the franchise quarterback in the nation's capital. That reality has made for a busy offseason in Washington. The Commanders have been wheeling and dealing over the past few months, swinging trades for Deebo Samuel and Laremy Tunsil. Offense has been the priority thus far, potentially opening the door for defense at the draft.

Washington has the luxury of going in whatever direction they want, but pass rusher and defensive back figure to be priorities throughout the event. Bottom line, the Commanders are entering uncharted territory – the weight of great expectations. The Washington Commanders entered the 2025 NFL Draft with transformation in mind. As Adam Peters steers the front office and Dan Quinn establishes a renewed culture of toughness and precision, Washington sought to plug key roster holes while continuing their ambitious roster makeover. Without a third-round pick, the Commanders had to maximize value with every selection. Their approach showed a smart balance of long-term thinking and short-term impact.

It set up a critical season for a team with rising expectations. Heading into the draft, Washington's most urgent need was clear. They had to replace Dante Fowler Jr. He led the team in 2024 with 10.5 sacks but left in free agency. The lack of a true edge presence put pressure on finding a pass-rushing solution. The secondary, while bolstered by the acquisition of Marshon Lattimore, still needed depth and developmental talent at cornerback and safety.

On the offensive side, uncertainty loomed large over the wide receiver room. Four top contributors—including Terry McLaurin and newly acquired Deebo Samuel—are on expiring contracts. Reinforcements were needed to ensure franchise quarterback Jayden Daniels had weapons beyond 2025. Offensive line depth was also on the radar after investing heavily in Daniels' protection during free agency. Here we'll try to hand out grades for every pick that the Washington Commanders made in the recent 2025 NFL Draft. Protecting Daniels is mission-critical.

As such, drafting Josh Conerly Jr was a forward-thinking move. Conerly's stock steadily rose throughout the college season thanks to his elite athleticism, smooth footwork, and increasingly polished technique. Sure, Washington already boasts veteran tackles in Laremy Tunsil and Brandon Coleman. However, Conerly brings insurance, competition, and a possible heir apparent to a crucial position. Critics might argue that passing on immediate defensive help was a risk. Still, you can't fault the Commanders for investing in the long-term security of their franchise QB.

With the growing volatility of offensive line play across the NFL, having three starting-caliber tackles is a luxury most teams would envy. The Commanders struck gold late in the second round with Trey Amos. He is a physical, aggressive man-to-man corner. Amos perfectly complements Marshon Lattimore's style. He has the instincts to thrive in Quinn’s defense, which leans heavily on press coverage and tight windows. Amos isn't just a plug-and-play option.

He could also emerge as a full-time starter by midseason. His ball skills, competitiveness, and resilience against big-bodied receivers address a critical need in the secondary. Peters prioritized getting a young, ascending talent in Amos without overreaching. This one could pay immediate dividends. Adam Peters only had five picks at his disposal heading into the 2025 NFL Draft. Almost everyone expected the general manager to move back at some stage to bolster his assets.

He opted to stand pat and go with quality over quantity instead. The Washington Commanders put themselves in a fantastic position beforehand. Peters made some bombshell trades, signed veteran free agents ready to win now, and retained almost all of their major contributors from the previous campaign. This provided Peters with a sense of freedom to stick or switch as he saw fit. Offers came along. Peters resisted, taking prospects high on his draft board who represented better value than accumulating additional wealth.

And it was once again another outstanding haul from the front-office leader. The Commanders missed out on filling one critical need, but it's how the board fell. That was the price Peters was willing to pay to find Pro Bowl-caliber performers in the trade market. Now, attention turns to preparing for the upcoming campaign as Washington looks to go one better next time around. That's for the future. For now, we delved deeper and graded every Commanders pick from another eventful 2025 NFL Draft.

The Washington Commanders entered the 2025 NFL Draft in unfamiliar territory. Drafting at 29th overall was the lowest draft position the franchise has earned since 2002 when the team selected quarterback Patrick Ramsey. This would be head coach Dan Quinn and general manager Adam Peters’ second crack at the draft after hitting a homerun second overall just a season ago. The general consensus seems to be that the Commander’s played this one safe. The Ringer’s Chad Kelly writes that the team ‘hit this one right down the fairway’. The grades ranged from a low B- to a perfect A.

Overall, based on the grades from seven different analysts, the Commanders finished the 2025 NFL Draft with a GPA of 3.3. The team’s lone perfect grade came from CBS Sport’s Chris Trapasso. Though the team only had five selections on the weekend, Trapasso awarded the middle three picks individual grades of an A, A+, and A-, respectively. He was a fan of every selection and is sipping the Adam Peters kool-aid. “General manager Adam Peters is rising star in the industry. Two drafts in, that’s safe to say,” Trapasso wrote.

“Conerly was the pruden albeit non-sexy pick in Round 1. Amos has a high floor at boundary corner — a clear need opposite Marshon Lattimore — and Lane is a dynamic slot receiver with 4.34 speed and wiggle post-catch. Croskey-Merritt absolutely has the size, cutting skill and effortless power to be a tremendous seventh-round find at running back.” Pro Football Network awarded an A- for Washington’s efforts. The website approves of the Connerly pick, and believes they may have made the best selection of day two by picking up Ole Miss’ Trey Amos. The Cinderella story of the 2024 season, the Washington Commanders exceeded all expectations by reaching the NFC Championship Game.

However, Jayden Daniels and Dan Quinn won’t be sneaking up on anyone this time, putting the pressure on the Commanders to nail the 2025 NFL Draft. Let’s break down and grade each of Washington’s picks. Looking for all 32 teams’ draft grades? Head to our 2025 NFL Draft Grades for All 32 Teams Tracker to see how we’ve graded other drafts. The Commanders didn’t have an abundance of capital in the 2025 NFL Draft, but they used the capital they had fairly well. Bolstering the offensive line will always be a fruitful move, and Josh Conerly Jr.

gives the Commanders both high physical upside and flexibility with the other personnel. Trey Amos was one of the best value additions on Day 2, as he grants Washington early starting ability and schematic versatility. On Day 3, the Commanders only had three selections, but they still managed to add a dynamic playmaker in Jaylin Lane, an athletic coverage linebacker in Kain Medrano, and a potential gem at RB... The Commanders can expect immediate returns from their early-round picks, and the late-rounders have potential, too. It’ll be up to Washington to shuffle their line the right way, but a starting lineup of Tunsil-Coleman-Biadasz-Cosmi-Conerly can dominate the line of scrimmage, and help Jayden Daniels and the offense take yet another... The Washington Commanders were busy once again this offseason, as general manager Adam Peters worked to retool the roster with trades and veteran free agent signings.

Now, it's time to continue building for the future with the 2025 NFL Draft in Green Bay, Wisconsin. The Commanders will begin the three-day even with five picks, including the No. 29 selection. Some of their picks have been moved to acquire talent like Laremy Tunsil and Deebo Samuel from the Houston Texans and San Francisco 49ers, respectively. Because of those moves, the Commanders do not currently own a third-round pick, although that could change by the end of the night. Here's a full look at how the order currently stands for the Commanders.

Come back tonight for more updates on what the Commanders do in this year's draf! The Washington Commanders enter the 2025 NFL Draft on Thursday with five picks over the three-day event. The NFC runner-ups have parallel tracks running in this year’s draft. There are no glaring holes at any position, but Washington still needs more youth, speed and upside across the roster. However, the Commanders have only five selections in 2025 and 2026 following three trades for established veterans. With their first selection at No.

29, the Commanders took Oregon offensive tackle Josh Conerly Jr., adding to a line that now also includes five-time Pro Bowler Laremy Tunsil. General manager Adam Peters would love to add picks for more draft-day swings, knowing they need upgrades at edge rusher, cornerback and offensive playmakers around quarterback Jayden Daniels. Keep coming back here throughout the draft for grades and analysis of each Commanders pick. The Commanders were uber-aggressive this offseason in trading for Tunsil, and now they fortify the other side with Conerly. In the 2024 regular season, Conerly (6-foot-4, 315 pounds) allowed just four hurries, one hit and one sack, according to Pro Football Focus, and started his final 28 games for the Ducks. BREAKING: The Washington Commanders have selected Oregon offensive tackle Josh Conerly Jr.

Commanders 2025 Draft Grades Report Cards For Every Player Taken

People Also Search

The Washington Commanders Were One Win Away From A Super

Washington Has The Luxury Of Going In Whatever Direction They

It Set Up A Critical Season For A Team With

On The Offensive Side, Uncertainty Loomed Large Over The Wide

As Such, Drafting Josh Conerly Jr Was A Forward-thinking Move.